The Kalām Cosmological Argument and the Muslim Concept of God (QoW #1018)
A listener who accepts the kalām cosmological argument asks whether Ockham's Razor points toward a strictly unitarian God rather than the Trinity. The listener also wonders whether objections to the Islamic concept of God come more from cultural assumptions than from careful reasoning. Dr. Craig considers what the kalām argument can and cannot tell us about the Creator, where his belief in the Trinity actually comes from, and how his own study of Islam bears on the question.
Guest (Male): Dear Dr. William Lane Craig, I hope this message finds you in excellent health and spirits. I would like to begin by expressing that you are a true role model to me. I deeply respect your work, hold great affection for your intellectual journey, and genuinely wish you all the very best. I am writing out of a sincere desire to convey my profound appreciation for your relentless academic labors and your robust, logical defense of theism. Your revitalization of the Kalam cosmological argument and your rigorous deconstruction of modern materialism have left an indelible mark on contemporary philosophy.
As a researcher following your work, I find myself in complete agreement with your premises. The universe has an absolute beginning, nothingness cannot produce being, and this universe must have a first cause that is all-knowing and all-powerful. However, a pressing philosophical question arises regarding the ultimate nature of this first cause. Considering the principle of parsimony, Occam's razor, wouldn't absolute monotheism, the existence of a singular, eternal, uncompounded, and unincarnated God be the most logically coherent and simple conclusion derived directly from the kalam argument itself?
How do you evaluate this strict monotheistic model compared to more complex theological models? Furthermore, in all candor and respect, it often appears to an outside observer that certain objections raised against the Islamic conception of monotheism might stem more from existential or cultural frameworks rather than purely deductive necessity, acting as a barrier to evaluating prophetic claims objectively. I would be deeply honored to hear your perspective on this distinction. It is my sincere dream that you read these words personally, and I would be immensely grateful for any direct line of communication with you, should your time permit.
Thank you very much for your time and for reading this letter. I wish you continued brightness and success in your intellectual pursuit. With the highest respect and warm regards. Al-Azhar.
Dr. William Lane Craig: Thank you for your gracious letter, Elazar. I have great respect and even affection for those medieval Muslim theologians who developed to such a high degree the ancient Kalam cosmological argument. So naturally, your question was one with which I was confronted in my original doctoral work on the argument at the University of Birmingham. My belief in Trinitarian theism is obviously not based on the Kalam cosmological argument, which taken in isolation goes no distance to establishing a multiplicity of divine persons. Rather, my belief in the Trinity is rooted in the self-revelation of God in Jesus of Nazareth.
It was and is the radical personal claims of Jesus to divine authority, whereby he put himself in the very place of God, ratified by God's raising him from the dead, that forced a change in Jewish monotheism to discerning multiple persons in God. So the real issue, it seems to me, is how we understand Jesus. The principle of parsimony, or Occam's razor, states merely that we should not multiply causes beyond necessity, that we are justified in postulating only such causes as are necessary to explain the evidence. But the principle does not rule out that the true explanation may in fact be more complex than is required.
So Occam's razor does not rule out that the cause of the universe established by the Kalam cosmological argument is a Trinitarian God. It implies only that we would be unjustified in inferring a Trinitarian God as the explanation for the beginning of the universe. and no one does that, of course. What you call absolute monotheism is intended to be unitarianism, I suspect. You and I agree that the cause of the universe is singular, that there is only one God. We also both agree that this cause is eternal in the sense that it never began to exist. But I think that we would be unjustified in inferring that the creator of the universe is uncompounded, if by that you mean simple.
For I think that the doctrine of divine simplicity is wholly implausible, if not incoherent. Al-Ghazali agrees with me here. Finally, we would not be justified in inferring that the Creator is unincarnated at some later time subsequent to creation, for there is nothing in the argument to rule out the possibility that the Creator of the universe might later enter into human history as an incarnate person. So at most, what Occam's razor tells us is that we would be unjustified in inferring Trinitarian theism on the basis of the Kalam cosmological argument alone. For that reason, I maintain that the argument shows merely that a personal creator of the universe exists, a conclusion which is neutral with respect to Unitarianism and Trinitarianism.
Now this brings us inevitably to the second issue you raise, namely, and I quote, that certain objections raised against the Islamic conception of monotheism might stem more from existential or cultural frameworks rather than purely deductive necessity. While that may be the case for some, I have to tell you that I personally find Islamic culture in many ways exotic and intriguing. My favorite country which we have visited is Turkey, which has of course not only Islamic culture, but also Christian Byzantine culture and modern Western influences. After finishing my doctoral work at the University of Birmingham in England, I went on to do doctoral studies in theology at the University of Munich in Germany.
As my side area of specialization, I chose Islam. So I read extensively in its history and theology and was examined for my doctoral degree in the subject. So I trust that my criticisms of Islamic theology, which you can find in my debates with Muslim scholars and clerics, are not unfair, but are carefully thought through. I have argued that the Islamic concept of God is morally defective and therefore incoherent, and that the Islamic understanding of Jesus of Nazareth is drastically flawed historically, and so cannot be true. This is not the place to rehearse those arguments, but I hope at least that you can see that my disagreements are not born out of prejudice or ignorance.
Featured Offer
The Daily Defender is a 31-day journey through the attributes of God, drawn from Dr. William Lane Craig’s Defenders Sunday school class. Each day features a verse of Scripture, a Defenders reading, and a short prayer designed to engage both the mind and the heart.
Whether you’re new to theology or have studied it for years, this daily reader will help you:
Grow in your understanding of the attributes of God
Cultivate a worshipful response to God’s greatness and goodness
Deepen your confidence to give a reason for the hope that is within you
Join the Reasonable Faith community as we grow together in our knowledge of God!
Past Episodes
Video from Dr. William Lane Craig
Featured Offer
The Daily Defender is a 31-day journey through the attributes of God, drawn from Dr. William Lane Craig’s Defenders Sunday school class. Each day features a verse of Scripture, a Defenders reading, and a short prayer designed to engage both the mind and the heart.
Whether you’re new to theology or have studied it for years, this daily reader will help you:
Grow in your understanding of the attributes of God
Cultivate a worshipful response to God’s greatness and goodness
Deepen your confidence to give a reason for the hope that is within you
Join the Reasonable Faith community as we grow together in our knowledge of God!
About Reasonable Faith
Reasonable Faith features the work of philosopher and theologian Dr. William Lane Craig in order to carry out its three-fold mission:
1. to provide an articulate, intelligent voice for biblical Christianity in the public arena.
2. to challenge unbelievers with the truth of biblical Christianity.
3. to train Christians to state and defend Christian truth claims with greater effectiveness.
Reasonable Faith aims to provide in the public arena an intelligent, articulate, and uncompromising yet gracious Christian perspective on the most important issues concerning the truth of the Christian faith today, such as:
the existence of God
the meaning of life
the objectivity of truth
the foundation of moral values
the creation of the universe
intelligent design
the reliability of the Gospels
the uniqueness of Jesus
the historicity of the resurrection
the challenge of religious pluralism
About Dr. William Lane Craig
William Lane Craig is Emeritus Research Professor of Philosophy at Talbot School of Theology in La Mirada, California. He and his wife Jan have two grown children. At the age of sixteen as a junior in high school, he first heard the message of the Christian gospel and yielded his life to Christ. Dr. Craig pursued his undergraduate studies at Wheaton College (B.A. 1971) and graduate studies at Trinity Evangelical Divinity School (M.A. 1974; M.A. 1975), the University of Birmingham (England) (Ph.D. 1977), and the University of Munich (Germany) (D.Theol. 1984). From 1980-86 he taught Philosophy of Religion at Trinity, during which time he and Jan started their family. In 1987 they moved to Brussels, Belgium, where Dr. Craig pursued research at the University of Louvain until assuming his position at Talbot in 1994.
He has authored or edited over thirty books, including The Kalam Cosmological Argument; Assessing the New Testament Evidence for the Historicity of the Resurrection of Jesus; Divine Foreknowledge and Human Freedom; Theism, Atheism and Big Bang Cosmology; and God, Time and Eternity, as well as over a hundred articles in professional journals of philosophy and theology, including The Journal of Philosophy, New Testament Studies, Journal for the Study of the New Testament, American Philosophical Quarterly, Philosophical Studies, Philosophy, and British Journal for Philosophy of Science. In 2016 Dr. Craig was named by The Best Schools as one of the fifty most influential living philosophers.