The Shocking Dangers of Replacement Theology
Is Replacement Theology undermining your understanding of God’s Word? Dr. Susan Michael breaks down why the belief that the church has replaced Israel contradicts Scripture and creates dangerous spiritual blind spots. She examines passages in Romans, Genesis, and Ezekiel to show how God’s unconditional covenant with Abraham remains active today. Discover the three major dangers of Replacement Theology—including how it fuels antisemitism and blinds Christians to end-times biblical prophecy—and learn how to view Israel through a balanced, biblical perspective.
🔔 Don't forget to like, comment, and subscribe for more content that informs, inspires, and empowers.
Guest (Male): Welcome to the Israel Answers Series, connecting Israel, the Bible, and you. Join Susan Michael as she explores timely issues and current events from a scriptural perspective to equip the Christian world with a balanced and biblical response. Be sure to subscribe for future episodes which will ignite your faith and bring the Bible to life in your everyday world. Now, let's join Susan with your Israel Answers.
Dr. Susan Michael: Hey there. Welcome to this week's Out of Zion podcast, and I am your host, Dr. Susan Michael. We are in the middle of a whole series about uh the rise of antisemitism and uh the crises that we are facing in both the church and in Israel because of that and because of uh rising biblical illiteracy and uh so I hope you've been listening in, and if not, please go back and listen to some of those introductory uh series before this one. This week, we're going to talk about the dangers of replacement theology. Now, last week, uh I shared what some of the things that lead up to replacement theology.
But I want to spend a little bit more time talking about it uh today. So, what is replacement theology? It is any theology that claims that God has rejected the Jewish people because they rejected Jesus as Messiah and has replaced them with the church in his plans and purposes. So, I want to dissect this a little bit. Um first is the whole idea that the people of Israel have been rejected for rejecting Jesus. Now, just a few points I want to make here about number one, their rejection of Jesus. Do you know that many more Jews accepted Jesus than those who rejected him?
So many were hailing him as king on his way into Jerusalem on what we call Palm Sunday. You know that story? That the Sanhedrin panicked about it. Um they were the it was the Sanhedrin. The they're the ones that turned Jesus over to the Romans for execution. So, let's talk about this for a minute. Um I have heard people say um ignorantly that the very people that hailed Jesus as king on the Mount of Olives turned against him in the courtyard and called for his execution. And I don't believe that to be true at all.
I don't think that's accurate. The people that were allowed into the courtyard where the Sanhedrin was bringing their charges would have been people known to the Sanhedrin and sort of a part of their group. Uh these that were believing in Jesus and hailing him as king uh would probably not have even been allowed to enter the courtyard. Uh so let's get that straight. Now, who was the Sanhedrin? Why did they do this? Yes, they were the religious leaders. They uh ran the the temple worship and all, but they were seen as the government body over the Jewish population under the Roman Empire.
And their job was to keep peace so that the Roman Empire wouldn't come in. They were so brutal and uh clamped down on the Jewish people. So, they were very concerned about keeping the peace. And that is why they turned Jesus over for execution because they did not want him creating some kind of an uprising uh which would have been an uprising against the Roman rule. And it would have brought down the heavy fist of the Romans. Now, I'm I'm not excusing. I'm only explaining to you what's going on behind the scenes. And um they did this because there were so many Jewish people that were believing in Jesus and uh acclaiming him.
And then after Jesus's resurrection and his ascension into heaven, we read in the book of Acts about thousands of Jews in Jerusalem who became part of the early church. The church was all Jewish for about 10 years before the story of Cornelius, the first Gentile converting. Uh it was a good 10 years that the church was all Jewish. The apostles were all Jewish, and they took the gospel to the Gentile world. So, if this is the case, why would God reject them? It doesn't actually make sense. And could God reject them? The apostle Paul said in Romans 11 that he was a Hebrew of the Hebrews.
He was trained under Rabbi Gamaliel, and he dismantles the whole idea that God has that Israel has been rejected. And he said very plainly, quote, has God rejected his people? And his answer was unequivocal. By no means. God has not rejected his people whom he foreknew. Okay? That's pretty clear. Um and another verse in Romans 11, he said even if they have rejected, okay? Some of them are blinded in part to this. So, he says, if their rejection brought reconciliation to the world, what will their acceptance be but life from the dead? And in later in that chapter, he says this.
Concerning the gospel, they are enemies for your sake. But concerning the election, they are beloved for the sake of the fathers. Now, what does election mean? They're calling their chosenness. Concerning their chosenness, they are beloved for the sake of the fathers. Israel remains beloved because of the covenant God made with Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, and repeated throughout the scriptures. So, let's be very clear here. God did not reject the Jewish people because they rejected Jesus as Messiah. Um speaking of the covenant that God made with Abraham, that that covenant established their calling and their chosenness and their mission to be a blessing to all the world.
That covenant cannot be revoked. It is an everlasting covenant, and it also is an unconditional covenant. It's not based on anything that Abraham was going to do or his descendants were going to do. There was nothing conditional in that covenant. So, God's Israel's status as God's chosen people found in that covenant is not dependent upon their universal belief in Jesus as Messiah. That covenant by God was initiated by God in Genesis 12 and 15, 17. It was put into effect thousands of years, part 2,000 years before Messiah was revealed. So, it can't suddenly be conditional upon their belief on him now.
And the scripture is very clear that this covenant is an unconditional covenant. All right? Um and it's an everlasting unconditional covenant that God would make Abraham a great nation. He would give him a certain piece of land, and he would bless the world through him. This role or calling to be the people through whom God would work to bless the world, it's an everlasting one. And scripture repeatedly affirms this. I'll just read you a few of the scriptures. Genesis 17:8 God promised Abraham the land of Canaan as an everlasting possession. Once Abraham entered the land, God reiterated the promise in Genesis uh 13:15 he said, all the land that you see, I will give to you and your offspring forever.
Then in Genesis 48:4 he says to Jacob, I will give this land to your offspring after you for an everlasting possession. So, he repeated it to Abraham, to Isaac, and here to Jacob as an everlasting possession. Why? Because it's part of an everlasting covenant. And in Ezekiel 37:25 God declared that his people would dwell in the land forever. That's a future-looking verse. It 's prophetic. But that one day they would be in the land and they would live there forever. So, everlasting means everlasting. And forever still means forever. So, God's covenant promises to Israel regarding the land, regarding their calling is not based on Israel's obedience.
It is based on God's faithfulness to fulfill these promises. They were unconditional. And let's remind ourselves in Psalm 89:34 God speaks here through the psalmist. I my covenant I will not break nor alter the word that has gone out of my lips. Now, um replacement theologians then try to say that the promises to Israel have been revoked. And uh so either that covenant with Abraham has been canceled or it's been redefined and spiritualized to apply to the church. So, in other words, he revoked his promises to Israel that it was with them. And of course, this completely challenges the idea of God's faithfulness uh which is throughout the scripture that God would revoke an unconditional promise to Israel.
And if he would do that, so what confidence do you and I have that his promises that we find in the word are not going to be revoked? But scripture affirms, the New Testament affirms here in uh Hebrews 6:18, it is impossible for God to lie. God only speaks truth, and he keeps his word. And the apostle Paul really uh so appreciative, he was so clear on this in Romans 11:29, the gifts and the calling of God are irrevocable. And he is saying this specifically about the Jewish people if you read the context. So, God's promises to Israel remain intact.
They are not canceled. They're not transferred to anybody else. I think the word is very very clear on that. Now, I also want to speak to the idea that Israel could be replaced by the church anyway because that that tells me that whoever is saying that doesn't understand the calling on the Jewish people and the calling on the church. They're actually two very different callings. They complement each other. They may even overlap a bit. But there's no way that the church can fulfill the role of Israel as established in the Bible. So, they are called, the Jewish people are called to be the people on Earth through whom God works to bring about his plan of redemption.
And through them, a fallen world has received already the redemptive products of the law, the covenants, the promises, the glory, even the Messiah, Christ Jesus himself. The apostle Paul lists all of these in Romans 9. He says these belong to Israel. So, through Israel, we get to benefit from the law and the covenants and the promises of God and the glory that he gave Israel. We we get to partake of all of that, but it was from them and through them. They are going to usher in the Messianic kingdom when Jesus returns to them in Jerusalem in fulfillment of the Davidic covenant.
Their role is not over. The Davidic covenant has not it needs to be fulfilled, and it's going to be fulfilled by the establishment of his eternal throne here on Earth. That is the calling of Israel. That's why they needed a land. They needed a place where God was going to do these mighty acts through them to give this redemption to the world. So, what's the role of the church? Our role is to take the good news of Jesus to the world. We are to proclaim to the four corners of the Earth the work that the Jewish Messiah did on the cross for this fallen world and that he's coming back to implement everything that he won on the cross.
That's what Matthew calls the gospel of the kingdom. The king is returning. The kingdom is coming, and it's coming to Earth. And the uh John saw in the book of Revelation the new Jerusalem coming down and merging with the old Jerusalem. So, it's going to happen all here on Earth, Jerusalem as the center. That is the message of the church, and we're to take it out to the world. The church does not replace Israel's calling. We're not moving to the land. We're not there to usher in the kingdom. They are. Our calling is to let the world know about it.
Our our calling's complement each other. They complete each other. Now, some people that believe replacement theology, they will quote 1 Peter 2:9. And it tells us that we as believers are a quote chosen people, a royal priesthood. And thus, the church, they will say, it's clear that we have now taken that chosen status. We're now the chosen people. We're now the royal priesthood. That's the role that was for Israel. It's now in the church. But this verse simply means that we are engrafted into the covenants, and we have become the beneficiaries of the wonderful blessings of God by becoming a part of his people.
Yes, we are his people. And yes, we are a royal priesthood before him. We share in that spiritual calling and the spiritual blessings on Israel. Paul describes this relationship in Romans 11 by using the image of an olive tree. Israel's the cultivated tree. Gentile believers are wild branches grafted into that tree. And Paul issues a very stern warning. He says, do not be arrogant towards the branches. It is not you who support the root, but the root that supports you. So, we are branches grafted into the tree. We do not replace the tree. Yes, it says some branches have been broken off.
But it says even they can be engrafted back in. So, the root of this tree represents God's covenants and the church draws from that root, not the other way around. Replacement theology fosters a spiritual arrogance that the apostle Paul is absolutely against. We are to honor the root. We are not to be arrogant and haughty is what he said in Romans. Now, the other thing that I find very interesting in this whole discussion about replacement theology is that if the Jewish people have been condemned by God and there's no future for the Jewish nation, how in the world do you explain the miraculous survival of the Jewish people over the past 2,000 years of exile and constant attempts by their enemies to destroy them?
And how do you explain their reappearance as a nation after being driven to the four corners of the world 2,000 years ago? There is only one explanation. And that is this, that God is fulfilling his promises made to Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, and David, and that are repeated throughout the Hebrew prophets. It is all coming to pass exactly as the Hebrew prophets prophesied and predicted that it would. When we understand this and how true and accurate the Bible is, that's when our Bible becomes the most exciting book on the planet. And replacement theology robs us of that exciting revelation.
So, now as I begin to bring this to a close, I want to talk about three reasons why replacement theology is actually dangerous. Um first of all, it makes a Christian susceptible to antisemitism. Now, believing in replacement theology does not make a person an antisemite, but it makes a Christian vulnerable to antisemitism. Why? Because if we believe the Jews were so bad that they lost their standing in God, then we believe any antisemitic slander that comes down the pipeline about them. And you know, eventually incorrect theology will birth bad practice. And that's exactly what happened throughout history.
Replacement theology was the theological seedbed or the theological foundation from which centuries of Christian antisemitism sprouted. And it started with anti-Jewish preaching in the church. That was translated into anti-Jewish legislation by the state. And centuries of this paved the way for the Holocaust. And that is, my friends, why this is so dangerous. We want to nip this problem in the bud. The second uh danger of replacement theology I want to mention is that it tarnishes the image of Jesus. You know, for centuries an arrogant church taught replacement theology and contempt for the Jews. It even condoned their maltreatment.
Therefore, listen to me closely. The Jewish people concluded that Jesus was a very bad person who brought hatred and bigotry, and they wanted nothing to do with him. So, replacement theology provoked Israel to revulsion at the thought of Jesus being their Messiah. We, the church, in our arrogance, contempt, and hatred tarnished the image of our Savior and made him repulsive. That is such a tragedy, and that's something we don't want to continue happening. The third danger of replacement theology is that it can blind Christians to the signs of the time. You know, if you hold a replacement view, the Jews have been rejected by God and replaced by the church, and their return to their ancient homeland in the last 100 years is just an anomaly.
It's a political accident. Has no theological significance. Well, the survival of the Jewish people after 2,000 years of exile and their modern in gathering from over 100 countries, I think it may be over 120 countries, in fulfillment of the many prophetic passages, all that is considered irrelevant. So, instead of understanding that God's time clock is advancing and that this return to their homeland is preparing the way for the next great act of God in which the Messiah returns to the planet and establishes the kingdom of God on Earth. Well, a blinded church will not understand the times that we live in.
And they may find themselves outside of the move of God in our day. Worst yet, they may find themselves working in opposition to it and opposing it. That we do not want. I don't know about you, my friend, but I don't want to miss what God is doing. I want to be right smack dab in the middle of it. Don't you? That's why this whole discussion is so important. I hope that you're following me each week as we go through this. And um you know, as I bring today to a close, I want to offer you a free resource.
We uh I'd like for you if you would like to learn more about replacement theology and maybe review some of what I've covered today. Uh we want to give you a little free downloadable of our e-book on replacement theology. So, uh you'll see a link to it in today's show notes. If there are no show notes down below in the platform you're listening, uh please go to our website at icejusa.org/shownotes and download our replacement theology free resource. So, I will see you back here next week, and we'll begin to bring this series uh to a close uh soon.
But I ask you to please be back here with me next week so we can go one step farther. And until then, God bless.
Guest (Male): We hope you have enjoyed this episode of Out of Zion with Susan Michael. Be sure to subscribe to Out of Zion now on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, YouTube, pray.com, Salem OnePlace, Salem Life Audio. Out of Zion with Susan Michael is a production of icejusa. All rights reserved.
Featured Offer
As tensions between Iran, Israel, and the United States dominate today’s headlines, many are searching for deeper answers.
Step beyond the chaos and into God’s Word with our free guide: What Does the Bible Say About Iran?"
Past Episodes
Featured Offer
As tensions between Iran, Israel, and the United States dominate today’s headlines, many are searching for deeper answers.
Step beyond the chaos and into God’s Word with our free guide: What Does the Bible Say About Iran?"
About Out of Zion
Embark on a transformative journey through the Bible and the Land of Israel with Dr. Susan Michael, USA President, International Christian Embassy Jerusalem. Each Out of Zion episode offers rich biblical insights, powerful teachings about the people and land of Israel, and fresh perspectives on God’s unfolding story. Be inspired, encouraged, and strengthened in your faith as you connect Scripture to its roots in the land where it all began.
About Dr. Susan Michael
For over 40 years, Dr. Susan Michael has advanced the International Christian Embassy Jerusalem (ICEJ) in the USA and worldwide. She serves as USA President and sits on the ICEJ’s international Board of Directors. She is frequently asked to address complex issues to diverse audiences—including antisemitism, Jewish-Christian relations, and Middle East affairs—and does so with clarity and grace. Dr. Michael leads the American Christian Leaders for Israel (ACLI), has authored books, such as Encounter the 3D Bible: How to Read the Bible so It Comes to Life, and has developed educational resources including the IsraelAnswers website, ICEJ U online courses, and curricula for Christian colleges.
Contact Out of Zion with Dr. Susan Michael
https://icejusa.org/
ICEJ USA
PO Box 332974
Murfreesboro, TN 37133-2974
(615) 895-9830