From Broken to Secure: How Attachment Styles Shape Sex, Love, and Addiction
📻 START YOUR WEEK WITH HOPE ON 𝙀𝙫𝙚𝙧𝙮 𝙈𝙖𝙣’𝙨 𝘽𝙖𝙩𝙩𝙡𝙚 𝙋𝙤𝙙𝙘𝙖𝙨𝙩
Licensed counselors JJ West and Doug Barnes welcome back Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist Marc Cameron, New Life LIVE panelist and author of Understanding Your Attachment Style, for part two of their deep dive on attachment styles and sexual propensities. In this episode, they unpack the Vacillator and Chaotic/Disorganized (Controller–Victim) patterns, then paint a hopeful picture of what it looks like to become a secure connector—even if you never had that growing up.
If you haven’t heard Episode 4 yet (Avoider & Pleaser), listen to that first and then jump into this continuation. Together, these episodes help men see why their sexual struggles are not random, but tied to how they learned to relate, attach, and cope long before pornography or affairs entered the picture.
☎️ 𝐄𝐏𝐈𝐒𝐎𝐃𝐄 𝐓𝐎𝐏𝐈𝐂𝐒 & 𝐃𝐈𝐒𝐂𝐔𝐒𝐒𝐈𝐎𝐍:
“What does the Vacillator look like sexually?”
Marc explains that Vacillators (anxious, preoccupied / ambivalent) grew up with inconsistent connection—a parent who was sometimes very present and sometimes absent due to travel, divorce, deployment, or instability. They learn to idealize connection, then protest when they feel let down, creating a push‑pull dynamic of intense pursuit followed by angry withdrawal. Dating can feel intoxicating: rapid emotional bonding, oversharing, and early sexual involvement, but once real life surfaces and the idealized picture collapses, Vacillators can flip from “you’re my soulmate” to “I’m done” almost overnight, often mistaking dopamine‑driven intensity for true intimacy.
“Is the Vacillator more ‘love‑addicted’ than sex‑addicted?”
JJ and Marc contrast the Avoider’s tendency toward sex addiction (using porn and sex as stress relief) with the Vacillator’s vulnerability to love addiction—chasing the high of romantic intensity and the fantasy of “the one.” Vacillators often believe there is a single perfect person who will finally meet their every need; when that illusion breaks, they detach and go looking for someone new who reignites the feeling.
“How does this show up in marriage and affairs?”
In marriage, Vacillators may start with high passion and frequent sex, especially as a way to feel reassured that the connection is real and not going away. When disappointment sets in, conflict escalates: the Vacillator protests with criticism and complaints, while an Avoider spouse often shuts down or withdraws, creating a classic Avoider–Vacillator cycle. Vacillator affairs tend to be framed as “I’ve fallen in love with someone else,” not just one‑night stands; they see the affair partner as a new ideal, while their spouse becomes the symbol of disappointment and lost connection.
“What about the Chaotic/Disorganized style—Controller and Victim?”
Marc describes Chaotic/Disorganized attachment as forming in homes marked by danger, abuse, addiction, and neglect, where the child’s primary task is survival. Over time, some become Controllers, having learned that in relationships “one person is in charge and the other is powerless,” while others become Victims, developing learned helplessness and trying to stay under the radar to minimize harm. In adulthood, Controllers and Victims often find each other and repeat the abuse cycle; touch has been paired with fear and adrenaline, so sex may become fused with pain, humiliation, and high‑risk behaviors rather than comfort and connection.
“How do sexual dynamics work between Controllers and Victims?”
For Controllers, sex is unilateral and utilitarian—it is something they demand when they want it, often as a way to discharge anger, exert power, or regulate their own nervous system. Victims may endure degrading or painful sexual acts primarily to stay safe and “keep the abuser calm,” seeing sex as damage control rather than mutual pleasure or intimacy. Marc notes that these patterns are tragically common yet often hidden, and that Controllers and Victims are among the least likely to seek help because of deep shame and an aversion to revisiting their traumatic story.
“Are my parents just to blame for all this?”
Marc is clear: attachment styles are explanations, not excuses. Parents themselves usually carried their own insecure attachment histories, and generational patterns can pass down even without malicious intent. Insecure attachment is not about assigning blame, but about understanding the strategies a child learned to survive—and then taking responsibility, as an adult, to recondition those patterns.
“So what does a secure connector look like sexually and relationally?”
Secure connectors grew up (more often than not) with caregivers who noticed feelings, named them, invited expression, and soothed distress, teaching the child that emotions are manageable and relationships can be safe. These adults can admit mistakes, ask for help, exercise impulse control, set and respect boundaries, and use words—not acting out—to express what’s going on inside. In sex and intimacy, secure connectors can make eye contact, care about their spouse’s experience, accept no, repair conflict, and see sex as the overflow of emotional connection, not just a release or a test of worth.
“Can I become secure if I never had that growing up?”
Yes. Marc explains earned secure attachment: the process, supported by decades of attachment and neuroscience research, of re‑shaping your relational style in adulthood. The steps include:
- Recognizing your attachment pattern and how it keeps you stuck.
- Developing a coherent narrative—making sense of your childhood story instead of avoiding it.
- Leaning toward the “opposite” growth goals (for Avoiders, learning to feel; for Pleasers, boundaries and voice; for Vacillators, integration and staying; for Controllers/Victims, safety, humility, and help).
- Practicing new relational behaviors repeatedly, like reps in a gym, until your brain literally rewires.
“How does all this connect to spiritual growth and sanctification?”
Marc and JJ link attachment work to spiritual maturity, arguing that “you can’t be spiritually mature and emotionally insecure at the same time.” God is the ultimate secure connector, parenting his children with attunement, comfort, limits, and steadfast love; learning secure attachment is part of becoming more like Christ in how we relate. They encourage listeners to “pick their pain”—either the pain of staying stuck in old patterns, or the pain of growth that leads to freedom, intimacy, and lasting sexual integrity.
📚 𝐌𝐀𝐑𝐂 𝐂𝐀𝐌𝐄𝐑𝐎𝐍’𝐒 𝐁𝐎𝐎𝐊 & RELATED RESOURCES
(Consider linking these in your show notes/store.)
- 𝙐𝙣𝙙𝙚𝙧𝙨𝙩𝙖𝙣𝙙𝙞𝙣𝙜 𝙔𝙤𝙪𝙧 𝘼𝙩𝙩𝙖𝙘𝙝𝙢𝙚𝙣𝙩 𝙎𝙩𝙮𝙡𝙚 – Marc Cameron
- A step‑by‑step guide to identifying your attachment style and “earning” secure attachment in your closest relationships; available through the New Life store and other major booksellers, including an audio version read by Marc. https://store.newlife.com/category/primaryfeature/understanding-your-attachment-style
- 𝙃𝙤𝙬 𝙒𝙚 𝙇𝙤𝙫𝙚 – Milan & Kay Yerkovich
- The foundational “love styles” and attachment resource that shaped New Life’s teaching and undergirds Marc’s work on individual healing. store.newlife.com/purchase/how-we-love-expanded-edition
- Sexual Integrity Resources – New Life
- Articles, studies, and tools on breaking sexual strongholds, integrating attachment work, and building healthy intimacy. https://newlife.com/blog/category/sexual-integrity/
🎟 𝐒𝐏𝐄𝐂𝐈𝐀𝐋 𝐎𝐅𝐅𝐄𝐑 – 𝐄𝐕𝐄𝐑𝐘 𝐌𝐀𝐍’𝐒 𝐁𝐀𝐓𝐓𝐋𝐄 𝐈𝐍𝐓𝐄𝐍𝐒𝐈𝐕𝐄
Ready to address the attachment roots of your porn use, affairs, or sexual acting out?
Use code 𝐄𝐌𝐁𝐏𝐎𝐃 when you register for the Every Man’s Battle Intensive to save on your tuition. This 3‑day, in‑person workshop helps men confront sexual sin, understand deeper drivers like attachment and trauma, and step into Christ‑centered brotherhood and accountability.
If finances are a barrier, scholarships and financial assistance may be available—call 800‑NEW‑LIFE to ask about options so cost doesn’t keep you from the help you need.
📧 𝐁𝐎𝐍𝐔𝐒 𝐂𝐎𝐍𝐓𝐄𝐍𝐓 & 𝐋𝐈𝐒𝐓𝐄𝐍𝐄𝐑 𝐐𝐔𝐄𝐒𝐓𝐈𝐎𝐍𝐒
Want extra tools and follow‑up content for Season 3?
EMBpodcast@newlife.com
with “Bonus Content” in the subject line to receive exclusive Every Man’s Battle Podcast resources.
Have a question or topic suggestion?
EMBpodcast@newlife.com
with “Podcast Question” in the subject line.
☎️ Need prayer, a counselor, or more info on workshops and groups?
👉 Call 800‑NEW‑LIFE or visit NewLife.com.
🎧 Discover more ways to listen & watch:
👉 Every Man’s Battle Podcast hub:
https://newlife.com/podcasts/every-mans-battle/
👉 New Life LIVE & other podcasts:
#EveryMansBattle #SexualIntegrity #AttachmentStyles #Vacillator #Controller #Victim #SecureConnector #UnderstandingYourAttachmentStyle #ChristianMen #FreedomFromPorn #RecoveryJourney #BiblicalManhood #ChristianCounseling
JJ West: Hey everybody, welcome back to the Every Man’s Battle Podcast. Thanks so much for listening. We know there are lots of options out there. You could be listening to hundreds, thousands of other shows. We're glad that you've chosen to listen to this podcast, and I hope that it's helpful to you.
I'm certain that today's episode is going to be helpful to you. If you haven't already listened to last week's episode, where Mark came in and started sharing with us the different sexual propensities of the attachment styles, you need to go back and listen to that. We're going to pick up the conversation and continue that today. This is great information for us guys. This is going to help us in our recovery from our sexual addiction, but it's also going to help us in our recovery in our relationships. That's a vital part of our recovery. Mark, Doug, happy podcast day.
Doug Barnes: Happy podcast day. I’m waiting for the cake.
JJ West: I want cake. I love cake. I love all sweets, as most people who know me know that. But man, we're so glad to have you back, Mark. Thank you so much for joining us. You did such a great job last week of sharing how the first two insecure attachments, the avoider and the pleaser, look sexually. We need to tackle the vacillator. We need to tackle the chaotic-disorganized, but then we also need to wrap up with what it's supposed to look like. How did God design this to look? We're excited that we get to dive back into this topic. Maybe we just need to pick it up right there with moving on from avoider and pleaser to the vacillator. What does the vacillator look like as a sexual being in that broken attachment?
Mark: The vacillator is another term for somebody who's anxious-preoccupied or also ambivalent, where they have conflicting feelings. This is a style that's on the anxious spectrum. Whereas the pleaser is more fearful-based and can have avoidant tendencies, the vacillator is more resistant-based. They push-pull.
Vacillators grow up in a home where they get inconsistent connection from a parent. They get some attention and connection, but then they're made to wait on that. That could be because they have a parent or a caregiver who is not available all the time because of physical proximity. Maybe they live out of town or in a divorce situation where custody is split.
It could also be a job where a parent frequently travels or goes on deployment if they're in the military, or they do shift work. So they get this connection and then they get made to wait on it. In the wait, they feel unseen, unknown, and misunderstood. When the parent comes back, they protest. They want to show the parent that they're upset, so they pout, they cry, and they throw themselves on the floor depending on how young they are. They want the parent to come and soothe them, but then they're resistant to the soothing and they push away again. It's a demonstration to say, "I'm hurt, I'm upset, don't do that."
The vacillator grows up and goes into adulthood longing for connection. The connection gets turned up on high, looking for this consistent connection that they didn't get as a child. Dating is just highly intoxicating for them because it's all about the things that they missed out on. It's all about time, attention, and connection with another person.
Of course, when you first meet someone, there's this idealization phase. There is in every relationship where the sexual attraction and physical attraction draws you to the other person. You tend to see them in this more positive light and you disregard red flags. But they can quickly get into a relationship. They can share too much too soon, and they can get into sexual relationships very, quickly.
Then real life sets in and they get let down, or they discover who the person truly is. They've built this idealized version of the person in their mind that is unrealistic. Now they see the person for who they are or they get let down, and all those feelings come flooding back and they protest. They do this push-pull. The relationship can really flip at that point where it's all of this intensity, emotional sharing, and sexual connection, and then all of a sudden, "Now I'm mad, and I push you away." I'm resistant to you coming back after me because I'm so hurt. You shouldn't have hurt me in the first place.
JJ West: When we're allowing them in, they're the kings and queens of hope and romance, and it's all going to be wonderful. So it gets really intense real quick, which I think is often why the avoider and the vacillator end up together. The avoider is looking for sex as that stress reliever, and here the vacillator is looking for that romance and connection, but they're offering it through sex.
Mark: Avoiders typically have not had somebody who pursued them, idealized them, or affirmed them so much. All of a sudden you're getting this, and it feels great. Everybody wants that. Everybody wants to be wanted, for someone to think they're amazing.
But then when that conflict happens, that's when the cycle occurs. The avoider deals by pulling away and the vacillator deals by pushing toward, but they push toward with complaints and criticisms. That doesn't really fuel a connection, and that's what they're really longing for. They're longing for the connection, but their way of going about trying to get the connection is through that protest, which pushes the very people away that they're trying to connect with.
They feel deeply disappointed because they tend to idealize. They build someone up in their mind. When that is not true, or they discover it's not true, they feel duped. Then they swing all the way the other way, which is why Milan and Kay Yerkovich describe them as the vacillator. They're all over here and then they vacillate and they're all over here. Then they detach, and it's over.
Again, the vacillator pursues sex to relieve anxiety, but they mistake this intensity for intimacy. It's all about dopamine, dopamine, dopamine. Then when that goes away, it's like, "Oh, well, I guess I'm done. I'm going to move on or I'm going to withhold so that you'll pursue me again."
JJ West: Or they think, "I made a mistake. I chose the wrong person. This isn't my person. This isn't the one who's going to give me everlasting happiness. It must be that person. Oh, no, it's not that person. It must be this one." They just keep looking for "the one."
Mark: They often look for the one. Like, there's this one person for me, this one amazing idealistic person for me, and I've just gotta find them in the world. I thought I found them in you, but you duped me. You tricked me. You didn't really show me who you were.
But who duped who? The vacillator duped themselves because they idealized. Also, the vacillator didn't show this side of them to the other person also, because they may have run away if they'd known that all of a sudden they're going to swing and then they're going to criticize and they're going to devalue me.
A vacillator wife can often appear that she has a higher sex drive than her husband. It's not because she necessarily has a higher sex drive; it's that mistaking that physical connection for the intensity of intimacy because they want connection that they can feel to know that it's not going away. Sex is the highest form of connection, physical connection, you can have with another person.
When they protest and they're separate from the other person, that anxiety builds. So oftentimes sex is used also as a makeup tool, and it can be very intense. But if they get to that point where they devalue somebody and then it's detached, a cutoff can happen at that moment. Then they go looking for someone else. But if they are in a marriage, then they can have affairs. Their affairs look more like, "I'm falling in love. I've fallen in love with someone else." Not the one-night stand that the avoider does. This is a, "I've fallen in love with someone else."
When you start to build connection with someone else, when you have an addiction or something like that, that becomes the master. You can't have two masters. Jesus said that. You can't love God and you can't love money; you're going to obey one and not the other one. So when you fall in love with someone else, then you're going to detach from this other person, your spouse. It can be very hard to get the vacillator back because they think, "I've lost that loving feeling." There's a song about that. I've lost that loving feeling and therefore that loving feeling can't come back yet. And now I have it with this person. But affairs are fantasy; they're not real life.
JJ West: In our first episode with Mark, I talked about how he was reading my mail when he was talking about the avoider. I'm curious if you're having a similar experience, Doug, as he talks about the vacillator.
Doug Barnes: Actually I am. I'm sitting here just thinking relationship after relationship after instance after instance where many of the things that have been said just now, I've experienced firsthand all the way through to the detachment. I mean all the way through to where it was pursuit, it was love, it was the best thing since sliced bread, and then, "Oh, you pissed me off. Okay, well, I'm going to go to the next one."
That was a pattern for a long, long time. Even when I got married, I've learned how to stay within the guardrails. I try not to go all good and all bad. I'm learning how to stay in the middle where I'm asking to get needs met. I'm not expecting her to read my mind to already know what I need. That's been huge for me, and to know that we can disagree and still be connected. I don't have to complain, I don't have to protest, although it catches up with me every now and then. I'm less protesting today than I was 14 years ago when I first started this looking at attachment style. So yeah, I'm resonating with it all. Trust me, it's there for sure.
JJ West: I think about how with the vacillator, because there is this striving for the ideal, and of course we never reach the ideal. Reality never reaches the ideal, and so I'm miserable because I'm not experiencing the ideal. Part of healing is in being okay with what's real rather than the ideal.
Doug Barnes: That's huge for me especially because now I'm getting to that point to where it's okay. I'm learning to recognize when what's inside of me is pushing towards that ideal, that picture I have in my head that says, "This is perfect." I'm learning to recognize when I'm starting to go to that place and go, "Hold on, no, that's not real life. What I have and experience, that's what's real." I have to talk myself off the ledge a lot. A lot. And I'm doing it in a healthier way now.
JJ West: I remember I was working with this one couple and the wife was the vacillator and the husband was the avoider. She had gotten to the point where she was disconnecting because, "This isn't fulfilling me. This isn't what I wanted. This isn't what I was looking for when I got married."
She was also into theatre, and so she talked about how she felt like, "I've outgrown this role and I need to go find a new role." I said, "I understand that because I grew up doing theatre myself. Sometimes that's the case that we go from one role to the next. But sometimes we get a role where it's a long-running show. We have to learn how to experience that role in a new way because the audience coming in the next time I perform, it's the first time for them, but you've been doing it for 180 days. It's gotten to the point where you know exactly all the lines, you know all the cues, you know all the reactions, and you feel like this just isn't doing it for me anymore."
But you have to find a way to bring a new aspect of yourself into that role. I think that's often times what the vacillator has to do in marriage or in a significant relationship. Instead of going, "Oh, I had this for a little while, it was all great, it was wonderful, it was intense for a little while and now it's fizzled so now I need to go find something over here," it's, "How can I learn to bring a new aspect of myself into this role? How can I open up more of myself into this role as opposed to looking for someone else to do that for me?"
Mark: I love that metaphor, and like Doug, I'm a recovering vacillator. My wife too; we're both recovering vacillators. So you can imagine what that was like. We were intense very quickly, married within three months. We didn't know one another, and then real life set in, and then the fireworks were a different type of fireworks that were going off. It wasn't Fourth of July nice fireworks; it was more like rockets happening, like a war zone.
For the vacillator, leaning toward the opposite is because they swing. They need to be more integrated as Doug was saying, learning to find that middle ground. I love the metaphor that you gave, which is learning to basically show up differently. If I show up differently in this same relationship, how does that change it?
Vacillators just move on living life for the intensity. If you just, yeah, exactly, so it's all about dopamine. They don't realize it. They say, "Oh, I have this just strongest connection with this person," and what that means is, "I have a lot of dopamine going on right now and it feels really good."
But if they really look at the history of their relationships, they'll see that happened over and over and over again. How come you have a lot of dopamine and you think this person's the one and you're greatly connected with them, and then all of a sudden you don't have the connection anymore and you want to detach? You'll never be happy as a vacillator because you won't find your ideal. It doesn't exist.
Even if you find someone and they are your ideal, healthy things grow. So you should grow in your relationship. That person, you will either grow and change and so they won't be your ideal anymore, or they will grow and change and they all of a sudden won't be your ideal anymore. You can't ever get to your ideal because it doesn't exist or it limits you or them from ever changing, which is not the nature of how relationships go.
There is a societal influence or a cultural influence. For the avoider, there's the cultural influence of a sex-saturated society, sex-saturated media, and pornography where you can escape into this and you'll feel good. I think for the vacillator, there is this fairy tale that's presented over and over. If you can find your prince or princess, if you can find this fairy tale, you'll have the fairy tale ending. It's available to you if you just find the right person and the right situation. It's just as much of a lie as pornography is.
Hollywood movies are really about the beginning stages of a relationship, everything being amazing. Or they're about the ending of a relationship where, "I'm done with this person." There's more about the beginning stages, though. So it primes us to think that there is this person who's out there and it's all natural. When we find them, it will just flow and it will be organic. This is what the vacillator expects. They often don't realize that they're idealizing, but the expectation that something is organic and someone will read your mind and know what you need without you having to tell them and they won't let you down—that's idealization. So yeah, we get primed by Hollywood for this type of relationship.
Doug Barnes: One of the best tools that helped me learn how to connect heart-wise over sexual was the comfort circle. It slowed me down so that making it an ideal didn't go as fast, and so I could recognize it quicker when that was coming up where that picture I have in my head that says, "This is perfect," was starting to go to that place. I could go, "Hold on, no. That's not real life. What I have and experience, that's what's real." I have to talk myself off the ledge a lot, and I'm doing it in a healthier way now.
JJ West: New Life Ministries saved my completely broken marriage. No matter how much hurt you've had to face, no marriage is beyond hope. At New Life Ministries’ Intimacy in Marriage weekend, licensed counselors will help you rebuild communication skills and renew your commitment to each other. You don't have to settle for a miserable marriage or even one that's just okay. It's possible to experience a new level of intimacy and to have a great marriage. To register or to find out more, call 1-800-NEW-LIFE or online at newlife.com.
Let's talk about the final insecure attachment, the chaotic-disorganized.
Mark: The chaotic-disorganized typically occurs when a person grows up in a home that is dangerous. Usually in this home there's addiction—drugs, alcohol—abuse, and neglect. This person's exposed to dangerous situations, and so their needs are basically reduced to learning to survive in this home.
Somebody who has a disorganized or a chaotic attachment really can have tendencies of all the different insecure attachment styles because they try everything and either nothing works or they get bounced around between different family members or foster care homes and they have different attachment figures in their foster parents who they have to learn to attach separately with or differently with, so they learn different strategies.
Milan and Kay observed in their book *How We Love* that when somebody goes through prolonged, pervasive abuse, they can go to one of two ways. They can become a controller because they learn that relationships are like this: one person is in charge and they get to control and abuse the other person and this person can't do anything about it. So they either become the controller or they become the victim. The controller says at some point, "I'm big enough and strong enough, I'm going to fight back and I won't be in the one-down position, so that means I'm going to take this position." The victim learns that, "I can't do anything to prevent abuse. It's helpless, it's helpless." They develop something called learned helplessness. It's going to happen. I just, if I stay under the radar then maybe it won't be as bad.
These two often find one another in adulthood and they end up in the cycle of abuse where this person feels like they can't leave, even if a door is open for them, and this person finds people who they're going to control and they need to monitor them. So when it comes to sexual propensities of these two, touch in these homes, if it's abusive, touch is not nurturing, it's not gentle, it's not comforting. You're being beaten, and so it's paired with this adrenaline.
So touch gets paired with adrenaline, and so these folks can become thrill-seekers. When it comes to sex, pain can then be paired with sex because that's what I'm used to. I'm used to adrenaline, I'm used to cortisol when it comes to touch. This type of touch should have, must have adrenaline and cortisol, so controllers can require their spouses to endure painful sex acts and humiliating sex acts, and victims can endure that.
It's tragic, but you're absolutely right. I mean, that shows up again and again. You do have these very—it's obviously broken. Some of the other insecure attachments, how the sexual propensities of those, they're more easily hidden. They can be explained away to a degree like, "Oh, that's just kind of the way I am, I'm a people pleaser or I'm just not a hugger." But abuse can't really be explained away. It's so much more obvious, but it happens so frequently.
There's a need to control. "I'm in charge," and so sex for the controller is very unilateral. It's not about connection; it's about what I want when I want it. I'm not trying to have a connection with you; I'm just using you. Oftentimes, and again, this is not about gender, because all of these attachment styles can be either gender. More often what we see, though, is a controller will be a male in the relationship because they typically are just the stronger person in there. Men need sex to relax, and so they get angry very quickly, they get volatile very quickly. Again, sex is used as a way to relax and calm them down as a release.
JJ West: And then what does sex look like for the victim, then?
Mark: Well, for the victim, it's a way to calm down my abuser. It's a way for me to make it better. If you're satisfied, if your needs are met, then you're not going to make life hard for me. Similar to the pleaser where there's this anxiety, but really it's about physical safety most of the time for them. So really it's survival. If I calm you down, then it's survival for me.
It's important to note that these attachment styles—and we're not blaming the parents for the attachment—we're just really explaining why we become a certain way. Obviously your parents had their own attachment figures in their parents and they did too. So we tend to see that insecure attachments can go down on generational lines. It doesn't necessarily also mean that because your parent had one attachment, you're going to have that same one. If you have a vacillator parent, you could become the pleaser because you're calming them down. But an insecure attachment can't produce a secure attachment; that we know for sure. You have to be securely attached to produce a secure attachment style.
These strategies are about learned strategies for what I had to deal with. It's not our fault that we learned this, because in childhood we are generally in this one-down position. We don't get to choose our family, we don't get to choose our environment, we don't get to choose where we go to school, our parents' discipline, their rules. But when we get into adulthood, now we become peers with people we should and we have more power, we have more responsibility. It's on us to learn to recognize this and learn how to reshape.
Unfortunately, for the controller and the victim, they're the least likely to seek help. Controllers are the more likely for people who do want to help to give up on, and victims because victims don't leave. You give them a way out and they don't leave, and then controllers, you're just mad at.
Relationships for them, this seems like it's normal for them. They are full of shame, so they're not going to go and say, "Oh," a controller's not going to go and say, "Hey, I think I have an anger management problem." They can go to anger management if they get court-ordered or if people find out about the abuse, then they might end up going. But they don't want to go back and explore their childhoods. That's the thing, because in order to be able to heal, you have to go back and make sense of what happened to you. Research shows that part of earning a secure attachment is to build a coherent narrative. "Coherent" is something that makes sense; "narrative" is story. I've got to make sense of my childhood story. Well, they don't want to go back and talk about that because for them it's—I have to relive this if I talk about it. I got out of there. It was so horrific. I'm never going back to that.
So they usually cope with life through addictions to numb the pain. And again, addicts, as we know, they're least likely to seek help because the addiction is the help. The addiction is the enabler. Exactly. I don't have a sex problem; I have a sex solution to my problem.
JJ West: Oh, that's so good. Okay, so let's shift the conversation then to what does it look like to be a secure connector and specifically as a sexual being. What does that look like?
Mark: Secure connectors are people who grow up in homes where they have a parent who understands and picks up on what they're feeling and approaches them and gives them language, asks them how they're feeling, puts language to it. I mean, how do you learn a language? Even if it's a foreign language in your adulthood, somebody says something, they tell you what it is, and then you repeat it back. How do you learn language as a kid? You pick something up and hear, "This is a banana," or "milk."
Securely attached parents also do that with emotions. They say, "Hey, you look sad. Your shoulders are dropped. You're looking down. Are you sad right now? Tell me about that." They notice, they observe, they put language to, they invite, and then they're soothers. They soothe the child. Every emotion has an emotional need to resolve it. If I feel misunderstood, then I need to be understood. Once I'm understood, that resolves my misunderstood. If I feel unheard, I need to be heard. If I feel sad, I need to be comforted. Secure parents learn to do that with kids.
These kids grow up learning that language for what's happening on the inside, and they go into adulthood believing that people can be soothers of stress and I can be a soother of stress. So they securely attached people find securely attached people, and they have a securely attached relationship. You can't take two insecure attachments and put them together and say, "Okay, now you'll be securely attached." They don't know how to securely attach. The math doesn't make any sense.
In order to have a securely attached relationship, if you're insecurely attached right now, your attachment style's insecure, you have to earn a secure attachment style, otherwise you won't find that. But they find one another. These relationships aren't perfect because there's no perfect people out there, there's no perfect parents, there's no perfect kids. This just happens the majority of the time in their childhood.
They do get let down, they do have problems in relationships, but they know how to resolve them. When their needs don't get met, they know how to self-soothe before they get highly reactive.
What does a securely attached person look like? They're somebody who can admit mistakes and they can ask for a do-over. They can ask for help when they're struggling. They can recover from mistakes without getting stuck in shame. They learn from them. They have impulse control especially when it comes to sex and sexual encounters and pornography and things like that. They can say no. Unlike a pleaser, they can hold a boundary. They're good listeners. They can seek understanding rather than seeking agreement, needing someone to agree with them. They have this highly reflective function where they can mirror, they can empathize, they can validate. They have awareness of their own state and they can communicate with language what's going on on the inside.
You're more likely to get your needs met if I can say, "Hey, I'm feeling sad. Can you give me a hug?" Then you know what's also going on with me. Most people act out their emotions if they don't have words for them and then you've got to try and guess what's going on. But someone who's securely attached has language for it, so they can ask for comfort, they can give comfort.
They're also comfortable with differences. They know that people are different and sometimes we need to learn how to compromise, sometimes we need to negotiate, sometimes we need to take turns, and they're good at doing that. So they can solve problems. All relationships have ruptures and they're good at repairing, and they can have compassion for other people too.
So they have—it's not that they don't have problems sexually or in other areas; they know how can we have a conversation to address this. They know that it's not just about my needs during sex. They're comfortable asking about their partner's needs. They're comfortable accepting a "no" if their partner doesn't want to do something, and they can be okay with that. They can make eye contact. They can have the emotional connection that leads to true intimacy, and sexual intimacy after that is that byproduct of that emotional connection.
JJ West: I think about the person who goes, "Phew. What you just described sounds great. I would have loved to grow up in a home like that, but I didn't have any of that or I had very little of what you just described. So does that mean I'm doomed? I can't possibly ever become a secure connector because I didn't have what you just described."
Mark: Sadly, many of us don't. Even if we are securely attached, it just means that we can do this more often than we react. But things happen in childhood that sometimes it's not anybody's fault. A parent dies, there's mental illness in a family, or a sibling's physically disabled, or a parent loses a job or something like that. Things happen that disrupt the cycle of bonding.
We can all continue to grow. This is what I outlined in my book, *Understanding Your Attachment Style*. It helps people understand the difference between the "how we are" and the "who we are." This is how we've been shaped, and so we can be reshaped. But you've got to recognize your attachment style because you can't change something that you're not aware of. So you first got to become aware and then you've got to see how that keeps you stuck. And then you've got to work specific growth goals. Like I said, you've got to lean toward the opposite because you've been conditioned one way, you've got to recondition.
I outline the growth goals for each of the attachment styles. It's kind of like you've got to go to the gym, right? You can't just say, "Well, I know diet and exercise. I got all the head knowledge." You actually got to go and you got to do the exercises, and that's where the transformation happens. This works because this is neuroscience. If you work the growth goals that help you lean the opposite way but into security, you will recondition and slowly over time, that's the way you earn that secure attachment style. It's what's called; it's called earned secure attachment style when you learn to recondition in adulthood because it's work; you've got to earn your way there.
In life, you have pain, so you've got to learn to pick your pain. I can pick the pain of staying stuck and in the same cycle, or I can pick the pain of growth, but this pain leads to freedom and that leads to true emotional intimacy. So don't expect that you'll have a securely attached relationship with someone else or a secure relationship if you yourself don't have a secure attachment. It just won't happen.
JJ West: Added to that, the fact that God is a secure connector. He parents us all the ways that you just described. He gives us language for our emotions. He makes room for our emotions. He is compassionate and comforting to us. He sets limits; he's able to say "no." The only thing in the list that you mentioned that he doesn't do is he doesn't own his mistakes because he doesn't make mistakes. But if he did, he would.
But that's the way God parents us, and so even if we didn't have it in the homes of our families of origin, even if I didn't experience it growing up, I can experience it from God, which then helps me to make that transition to become a secure connector.
Mark: A key part of owning mistakes is humility, and God, Jesus, modeled humility. One thing in the *How We Love* workshops that we do is we ask this question after we explain the different attachment styles: "Did Jesus look like an avoider? Was he not connected to emotion?" No, he cried when Lazarus died with Mary and Martha, even though he knew he was going to raise him back to life. Was Jesus a people pleaser? No, he could stand up to others. Was Jesus a vacillator? Did he just cut people off and rain the fire down like James and John told him to? No, he didn't do that. Jesus was secure in all of these ways. He wasn't a controller; he wasn't a victim.
Who created attachment? It's God's idea. Who created what the bond is supposed to look like between a mother—it's God's idea. Human beings are the only animals on this planet that have an attachment phase that lasts this long, that lasts 20 years. Other animals don't have that. So that must be important for our shaping and for our development. Even if you don't believe in God, there's a lot of atheist attachment research out there. The neuroscience backs it up. Many people don't believe in God, but they see that attachment is supposed to happen in one specific way. When that happens, we feel secure with that person and it shapes us, and that attachment style follows us into adulthood. A relationship is two histories colliding. You are the sum of all of your experiences and from those experiences, you formed belief and you formed adaptations to what happened with you, and patterns that you're stuck in. So if you find yourself in patterns that you don't like, then you have to learn to recondition and change your part in the pattern.
JJ West: That's a great segue. So if that just described you, that you are finding yourself stuck in a pattern that you don't like, okay, step one: go to the New Life website and order the book and start reading it. Start learning the things that I need to do to become, to earn a secure connector. It's available to all of us, no matter what our family of origin, no matter what my broken attachment style was coming into the game. I have the opportunity to learn a different way of connecting.
That's the good news. It's there within your grasp. You can do it. It's possible. It will take work. But also if you're a Christian, I mean, this is the path I believe to sanctification. You can't be spiritually mature and at the same time be emotionally insecure; that doesn't make any sense. So sanctification is a process. It's work that we have to do. Yeah, we're saved by grace, but we don't earn our right into heaven, but we work our way to sanctification by becoming more like Jesus. Earning secure attachment is parallel with that experience.
Mark, thank you so much. Thank you for the time that you've given to us, the valuable resource of your book that you've given to the world. Thank you for doing that. I can't wait for our audience to learn, grow, benefit, and begin to experience these secure connections that, as you said, God wants for us.
Mark: I might be biased here, but I think the best place to get my book is at the New Life online store.
JJ West: Fantastic. Don't wait, guys. Get to work. There's work to be done. We don't just wait for God to zap us. There's work to be done. What does God say when the Israelites are getting ready to go into the promised land? He says, "My spirit will go before you and I'll drive out all the -ites, all the inhabitants of the land. I'll drive them out from before you." At the end of the paragraph, he says, "So take up your sword and go drive them out." So it's a both-and. God is at work in us to change our broken attachment style into a secure attachment style, but we gotta pick up our sword and go to work and drive out all of the -ites out of our hearts.
Amen. I agree. Thank you, Mark. Thank you, Doug. Great to be on with you guys. Next week we're going to dive right back in. We hope and pray that you will join us again. Until we join back together, let's keep walking in integrity.
Voiceover: Thanks for listening. This podcast is one of many ways we can encourage and help you. If you’re looking for more help, visit us at newlife.com or call 1-800-NEW-LIFE. To receive bonus content exclusive to EMB podcast email subscribers, send an email to embpodcast@newlife.com with the word "bonus" in the subject line. If you have a comment about this podcast, we’d love to hear from you too. Drop us a line at embpodcast@newlife.com. And please remember to review, like, and share the podcast as it helps others find us. See you next week.
Featured Offer
Use discount code EMBPOD to save $100 when you register for the Every Man's Battle Intensive. The Every Man’s Battle Workshop is the place where men engage in the battle to get back their sexual integrity. In this intensive three-day workshop you’ll work with licensed Christian counselors who will arm you with the weapons you need for victory. The enemy may have wounded you, but the battle is not over. Register today. Too much is at stake not to take action.
Featured Offer
Use discount code EMBPOD to save $100 when you register for the Every Man's Battle Intensive. The Every Man’s Battle Workshop is the place where men engage in the battle to get back their sexual integrity. In this intensive three-day workshop you’ll work with licensed Christian counselors who will arm you with the weapons you need for victory. The enemy may have wounded you, but the battle is not over. Register today. Too much is at stake not to take action.
About Every Man’s Battle Podcast
New Life has been helping thousands of men with their sexual integrity for over 3 decades. Every Man's Battle podcast discusses the topics that will help men understand their challenges, the pathway to Christlike character, and hope for recovery. Becoming a man of sexual integrity is an ongoing process, and we can help you on the journey. New Life's EVERY MAN’S BATTLE PODCAST can assist you on the pathway to becoming the man you hope to be. As all things sexual integrity, EVERY MAN’S BATTLE PODCAST is for EVERY MAN!
Use discount code EMBPOD to save $100 when you register for the Every Man's Battle Intensive.
About New Life
JJ WEST
JJ is a Licensed Marriage and Family Therapist in private practice in Orlando. With a Master’s and Specialist degrees in Counselor Education, JJ began private practice after years of working with children, adolescents and families in outpatient settings. In 2009, he became an Every Man’s Battle Workshop facilitator, taking over as the main presenter in 2022. Before becoming a therapist, he worked for several years with college students in both Christian ministry and church settings. JJ is married with 2 adult children; and enjoys outdoor adventures, traveling to other cultures, good movies, and Florida State sports.
DOUG BARNES
Doug is a LifeCoach and Licensed Professional Counselor with Supervisor status working in private practice in the Dallas Ft. Worth Metroplex; working primarily with men and couples in finding restoration and redemption from sexual brokenness. His journey into becoming a clinician began in his teens and cultivated into a road to healing in his early twenties after the death of his father. He has worked with Every Man’s Battle Intensive Workshops as a facilitator since 2006. His passion is to give other men what God has given him—freedom. Doug has been married for 31 years and has 2 sons. He is a rollercoaster junkie, runner, all around fitness gym rat, and sometimes even breaks out his guitars to play.
Contact Every Man’s Battle Podcast with New Life
EMBpodcast@newlife.com
http://everymansbattle.com/
New Life
P.O. Box 1029
Lake Forest, CA 92609-1029
Phone Number
(800) NEW-LIFE (639-5433)