Oneplace.com

Confrontation and Forgiveness Part 1

February 8, 2025
00:00

We’ve all been hurt by the words or actions of another.  Maybe it was an unkind word spoken on social media, or someone has lied about you or stolen from you!  When that happens we have a choice to make… will we forgive them or not!  Today on A Daily Walk, pastor John Randall begins a study in Matthew eighteen, verses twenty-one through thirty-five. Jesus addresses the topic of forgiveness. 

References: Matthew 18:15-35

Announcer: Next time someone sins against you, keep this in mind.

John Randall: If I'm going to approach one who is erring, who's walking away from the Lord, I'm going to do so with a heart of humility and gentleness. I'm not above making that same mistake. If not for the grace of God, I could easily do that. If not for God's grace and his work in my life, any of us are capable of what somebody else is doing at the present time. So I understand that, so there's a sense of humility. I'm not judging, I'm just saying I love you, I'm concerned for you, and I know according to scripture, if you continue that way, this is what's going to happen. So please, please turn back.

Announcer: We've all been hurt by the words or actions of another. Maybe it was an unkind word spoken on social media, or someone has lied about you or stolen from you. When that happens, we have a choice to make. Will we forgive them or not? Today on A Daily Walk, Pastor John Randall begins a study in Matthew 18, Jesus addresses the topic of forgiveness.

John Randall: Here's Pastor John. Great to be back here with you. If you have your Bibles, if you'd open with me now to the Gospel according to Matthew chapter 18. This morning, I'd like to draw your attention to verse 15 as we consider together confrontation and forgiveness. Matthew chapter 18, beginning in verse 15. Moreover, if your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault between you and him alone. Now, if he hears you, you have gained your brother. But if he will not hear you, take with you one or two more, that by the mouth of two or three witnesses, every word may be established. And if he refuses to hear them, then tell it to the church.

But if he refuses even to hear the church, then let him be to you like a heathen and a tax collector. Now, within the Bible, there are a few words that are used to describe the church. The church has been likened to a flock of sheep, and as a flock, we have a good shepherd, the great shepherd of the sheep that we follow, Jesus Christ. The church has also been likened to a family. We are considered brothers and sisters in Christ. We have a father who is in heaven, who has adopted us and made us his own. And the church has also been characterized as a body. A physical body has many members working together.

So too in the church, it has many members that are working together, connected to one another for the glory of God. And there are moments when a physical body may suffer some form of sickness, and when you are aware of the illness, you seek to treat it. You could make the mistake of ignoring it, but you would more than likely get worse. So if you need medication, you take it. If you need rest, then you lay down. And the goal of treating the sickness in the physical body is restoration to health. In the same way, there are moments in the body of believers when the symptoms of sin may begin to show themselves, and in that moment, it is important not to ignore it, but instead to confront it.

And here within our text this morning, Jesus provides us with a four-step process when it comes to confronting sin within the life of a brother or sister in the family of faith. It begins, first of all, by recognizing that these words of Jesus are in the form of a command. In verse 15, it says, if your brother sins against you, go and tell him his fault between you and him alone. There are a couple of observations that one can make. For one thing, scholars are not sure whether the words against you are in the original, as be there are variations from the early manuscripts. Jesus is either referring to confronting a brother who sins in general or confronting a brother or sister who sins specifically against you.

Either way you look at it, whether it is personal or general, we have the responsibility to look out for one another in the family of faith. And by the way, again, Jesus said this wasn't an option. It was a command. For the sake of the health of the individual and their walk with the Lord and the health of the overall body of Christ, we are to go to that brother or sister. It's also important to keep in mind that the text seems to be pointing to a person, a Christian, who is living in unrepentant sin. It's not talking about, confronting someone for everything that they do. But rather, the Bible indicates there are times when love covers a multitude of faults.

This seems to indicate that when confrontation cannot be avoided because you are concerned about the well-being of the brother or sister who is in direct disobedience to the word of God, and they're living in willful sin, and they know it, and you know it, and at that moment you must step forward to speak to them. Understand that it isn't loving to let sin slide. The Corinthian congregation thought that they were being very loving and tolerant, and they even boasted about their acceptance of perverse sexual immorality within the congregation, and the Apostle Paul wrote to them and rebuked them for their actions.

They weren't helping the individual, nor were they causing the witness of Christ to be a blessing. Actually, they were failing to confront the sin that was in the church. Those who say, well, we don't really care how the people in our church live. that's between them and God. We, listen, we're not here to judge people, okay? We're not here to judge. That's not our place. You know the Bible says that in there. The main thing is that we all love Jesus, and we just love one another. Well, listen, that's not biblical love. That's not love according to the Bible. That's love according to a worldly culture.

If you truly love that person, there may be times when you have to go to that person and confront them in love. Proverbs 27, verse 6 says, faithful are the wounds of a friend, but the kisses of an enemy, they're deceitful. We may say we love a person who calls themselves a Christian who is living in sin, but if we're unwilling to approach them about it, then do we really love them? In reality, it's more likely that we love ourselves more than them because we don't want that person to be mad at us or not like us or not speak to us anymore, and so we'd rather tell them what they want to hear instead of what they need to hear.

If they're not a Christian, that's an entirely different subject. They need to be saved. They need to be born again. They need to hear the gospel, because once you are born again, that's when you become a new creation in Christ, and old things pass away. But this is more dealing with the person who claims to be a Christian, but willingly chooses to live in rebellion against God. They need to repent of their sin. Unfortunately, even today, there are many who are living under a false sense of security in a continual lifestyle of sin, and even some of the preaching that they prefer to listen to brings no conviction of their sin, but instead comforts them in it.

There are places that you can go where it is very soft on sin, and the word is not mentioned. We don't say sin, we say shortcomings. We don't say sin, we say oopsie daisies. We don't say sin, we say, oh, you know, we don't call it what the Bible calls it. According to Jesus, we are commanded to go to a person who is living in sin or sinning against us. However, when we do, we take the first step, and the first step, please note this, is to go to them privately. Privately, personally. Look at verse 15. If they sin against you, tell him his fault between you and him, and please underscore the word alone, alone.

By approaching the person privately, you keep the circle small for as long as possible. There's no need to go to everyone else. You don't need to go tell the world about what's going on. You don't need to go to your prayer time and pray about that situation with the person out loud that you haven't gone to them personally and shared with them. That's prayer and share. That's a dangerous thing. Lord, we just pray for Bill, you know, he's just really struggling right now, and I know nobody here knows it. Well, now they do, but you know, like, that's not right. Have you gone to them personally? I haven't, but I felt like the whole group.

No, that's not helpful. I really believe if we did what the Bible said was step one, it would solve 95 plus percent of the problems that usually follow skipping step 1. People just jump to step 3 without hitting step 2 or 1. A mistake that is so often made, sadly, is rather than go to that one person, you may go to another person or persons to build your case, to select a jury and tell them one side of the story so that they're on your side. And suddenly, yes, I feel emboldened now to approach that person, and I have people with me here to talk to you. We all feel this way. Do they? How did they even know about it until you told them?

Did you go to them personally? I didn't, but I felt... No, no, you skipped step one. And so as a result, you've fallen prey to the sin of gossip. Have you gone to that person? You remember when David had sinned so horribly that Nathan went to him personally and confronted him in his sin. That was his responsibility once it was revealed. Now, once you have gone to them privately, if they respond, if they repent, then listen, you leave it there. That's the end of it. We pray together, we move forward. There's no need to bring it back up again. On the other hand, if they do not repent after loving, humble, respectful, one-on-one private conversation, that is when you take step 2.

And let me just say to you that this whole thing of confrontation, the goal, you know what the goal is? Restoration. Like, like the goal is reconciliation. That's why you do it. If you're not willing to walk down the road of restoration, then you have no business going to them because this is part of the process. Now, if you take step 1 and they ignore it and they say, I'm not listening to you. I don't know what you're talking about. You know, you need to take the log out of your own eye, hello, before you try to take the splinter out of mine. And they start, using scripture in that way, judge not lest you be judged.

Y'all judgy. You know, you suddenly there's a problem. So what is step two? All right, you bring along a witness or witnesses. Verse 16, but if he will not hear you, take with you one or two more, that by the mouth of two or three witnesses, every word may be established. In presenting the second step, Jesus quotes here from Deuteronomy chapter 19. A principle was given by Moses to the nation of Israel, whereby you would have two or three witnesses to establish a particular testimony. When you bring in another person now it's no longer your word against theirs. You now have a another person who is able to listen and to observe and to see the response and the conversation.

And that can clear up any misunderstanding of what was being communicated. It also provides a level of accountability, and I think that is important. By the way, the one or the two witnesses that you bring along, they don't necessarily have to be eyewitnesses to what has transpired, but it is important for them to be godly, to be confidential, to be humble, to be loving, and that they also understand that the goal of this confrontation is restoration through this process. It's not having more than one person so we could gang up on this person. No, it's having more than one person to help provide assistance and accountability.

The Bible tells us in Proverbs chapter 11, verse 14, that in the abundance of counselors, there is victory. It's good to have more than one person there who can listen and observe and help. And prayerfully, as you take step two, the brother or sister will humble themselves, they'll repent of their sin, you can pray together, you can work through the problem with genuine repentance followed by restored fellowship. You would hope that after step two, that'd be the end of it. There's no further steps necessary. However, that's not always the case, is it? Jesus points out a third step may be required if there is still a failure to repent.

It says in verse 17, if he refuses to hear them, then tell it to the church. The first rebuke, it's completely private. The second, semi-private. The third is to be more public, involving the leadership in the church. Again, remember the goal is repentance, restoration, but for that to take place, there must be humility, there must be willingness to see what is presented, to receive it. If there is a hardening of the heart, if there is a doubling down on stubbornness and unwillingness to repent, then obviously there's still a problem. Some people skip step one, they go right to step three. That's been my experience.

Pastor John, you really need to go talk to them. Really? Have you talked to them? I haven't, but I think you should talk to them. They'll listen to you. I think you start with you and then bring two other people, and then after that come to me if it's necessary, or somebody in leadership in the church. But some people, they just jump right to, they want you to solve the whole thing. Like, A, I didn't create it. B, you need to take the two first two steps and then step three. Now, there are some teachers that emphasize the word church here, and found in this text that if a person who is willingly unrepentant, sinning, that they are to be brought before the entire congregation, and we all judge them.

Could you, that would be, that would be, there'd probably be a lawsuit on your hand. This would be, this is something people, first of all, someone's not going to come up and do that, but I believe in the, personally, this is my experience, and there are some churches that will do that, and that's something. but in my experience, I have found that the leadership that is called upon to oversee the church and the congregation has the responsibility to shepherd the flock and is not only called to deal with these difficult matters, but is also capable, through the power of the Holy Spirit to address the issue at hand.

In extreme cases, all right? In extreme case, and there are times and it when it can be extreme, and I would say I probably have a couple of those in my entire life of as a pastor of a church, where there there's an extreme case where somebody is a danger to the entire congregation, and it is everybody has to be put on notice because of this person's behavior. That has happened. It is a rare occasion, but sometimes, you have to do that. But for the most part, I do believe that there should be those who are able to oversee the work and to be brought in and to address the situation in step 3. So step 1, approach them privately, and if they're unreceptive and unrepentant, step 2, bring in other godly witnesses to provide assistance, but still, if they remain unrepentant, you take the third step, inform the leadership of the church, who then goes to the person who is in open rebellion and pleads with them, pleads with them to repent, presents what God's word says, where this is going to end for you.

Listen, if you continue to do this, listen, this is where it's going to lead. You come, let us reason together. Let's talk about it. Let's dialogue about this. This isn't, I'm not trying to win an argument here. I'm pointing you to scripture, and you can disagree with me, but you're ultimately disagreeing with God's word. This is what God's word says, and it's not going to end well for you. So you take that step, and if that doesn't work and they still are unwilling to repent, what do you do then? Ah, step four. This is the worst one. Step four. Notice it says, if he refuses, verse 17, to hear the church, well then, let him be to you like a heathen and a tax collector.

This is the final and last resort and the saddest thing that could happen. If a person is unwilling to repent and they choose to live in sin and they are hurting others in the process, there comes a moment when you have to break fellowship and just say, you're not welcome here. I mean, that's the worst thing imaginable. That's happened to me a couple times, I would say, in church, and that is painful. It's the worst thing imaginable. Sometimes it has to happen. If a man, for example, leaves his wife and children, leaves them and does not provide for them and is unwilling to repent, and yet he wants to come here to church.

I would say, you are not welcome here. And then we've been involved, we've gone through step three, we're already step four, and you are still unwilling to repent. You are not welcome here. Don't come here and think that you can bring whoever your next person is and just sit here and like, I just want to worship. This is my home church. Not anymore. Not anymore, it isn't. You need to go repent and get right with God and be restored to your family, or don't show up here. And if you do show up here, we're going to ask you not to come. I mean, that's serious, right? That's an extreme case that you would hope to avoid.

You have to understand, in the first century church, it wasn't like there was a church on every block. It wasn't like you could drive down the 5 freeway and just go to 100 churches in a matter of 5 minutes of each other. Because you could just, nowadays, you could call somebody out in love if it gets to this point, and they could say, fine, I didn't like this church anyway, so later, huh? And they take their sin down to the next church, and they don't know. They're new there. Yeah, I'm new here. I'd like to get involved. I just really feel called here. Do you? Do you really feel called here? You just take your sin somewhere else.

I mean, that sometimes that happens, and they show up, and these people, they don't know. And it's not like, you know, we're going to go around and say, hey, listen, I don't know if you heard, but somebody came here. Now, I mean, you might want to do a background check on this guy, because I'm just telling you right now, he gave us all these problems. But there has been times when people have called me, listen, have called me and said, hey, hey John, I'm so and so from such and such. I just want to let you know there's somebody who just showed up at your church and da da da da da da da. Really?

Guest (Male): Well, thanks for the tip.

John Randall: that's good to know. I mean, all right, eyes open. I mean, you don't know. That's the extreme case. But when you've exhausted every resource, when you tried everything you can possibly do to reason with the person to repent and they're still unrepentant, then church discipline has to be administered, and it is to be administered, again, in love, in concern, and you continue to pray for that person, hopefully that they'll come back. That's the goal, that they would be restored. I'll give you an example of this. You remember when Paul wrote to the church in Corinth, and they were boasting, as I mentioned earlier, about how tolerant they were of sin, so inclusive, the church of Corinth.

Oh, what a great place. Paul said, your boasting is not good. This is a bad idea. You need to turn such a one over to Satan for the destruction of his flesh. And guess what? They did. They turned him out. And it wasn't like you could go to, the church in Corinth, and the other church in Corinth, and the other church in Corinth. There was one church in Corinth. So when he was out, he was out. And the goal of turning him out is that he would realize, I need to repent and get back. And you know what happened? It worked. The guy repented, he was restored, the relationships were healed. It happened.

It worked because of church discipline, because the church loved the man enough to say, we love you, but you're not, you can't continue to do this. It's unacceptable. Paul said in 2 Corinthians 3:15, he said, don't regard such a person as an enemy, but admonish him as a brother. They're not my enemy, they're my brother. I'm hoping that they come back around. I believe that in writing to the church in Galatia, that the Apostle Paul presented a wonderful pattern to follow when you are put in a position where you have to actually confront someone who is living in unrepentant sin. And this is what he said, and I would encourage you to mark this passage, to remember it and use it.

In Galatians 6:1, it says, Brethren, if a man is overtaken in any trespass, you who are spiritual seek to restore such a one. How? In a spirit of gentleness, considering yourself, lest you also be tempted. If I'm going to approach one who is erring, who's walking away from the Lord, I'm going to do so with a heart of humility and gentleness. I'm not above making that same mistake. If not for the grace of God, I could easily do that. If not for God's grace and his work in my life, any of us are capable of what somebody else is doing at the present time. So I understand that, so there's a sense of humility.

I'm not judging, I'm just saying I love you, I'm concerned for you, and I know, according to scripture, if you continue that way, this is what's going to happen. So please, please turn back. James also makes mention of this in James chapter 5, verse 19. He said, Brethren, if anyone among you, listen to this, wanders from the truth and someone turns him back, let him know that he who turns a sinner from the error of his way will save a soul from death and cover a multitude of sins.

Announcer: Offering hope and encouragement for your daily walk, that is Pastor John Randall, and this is A Daily Walk. We're going through the Bible right now. You can order a CD copy of this message by calling 877-242-0828. You can also listen to our recent programs at our website, adailywalk.org. We also offer John's teachings at oneplace.com and have an app as well. To get our app, do a search for Calvary South OC. I should also mention John is on X and Instagram. You can start following him on X at PJ Randall 7 and on Instagram at John P Randall. You know, with Valentine's Day falling within the month of February, we picked out a marriage strengthening book for you and your spouse.

It could even be good to read if you're preparing to be married one day. It's Happily Even After: Doing Marriage Right by Barry Stagner. Would you like a better marriage? Do yourself a favor and get this book today. It is a good one, and we're making it available to you for the special price of just 7 dollars. Just call us at 877-242-0828 or go online to adailywalk.org. And thank you for your prayerful and financial support of A Daily Walk. It really is having an impact. With your help, we're able to reach thousands with the truth and love of Christ at a time when they really need to hear it.

If you'd like to donate to the ministry, please go to adailywalk.org or call us 877-242-0828. If you've been blessed as you studied along with Pastor John, there is one more thing you can do that would really be helpful, and that is simply email Pastor John to let him know. There's a place to contact us at the website adailywalk.org. You know, Pastor John loves to read listener letters and emails, so let him know what's going on in your life and how we can pray for you. That'll do it for this edition of A Daily Walk with Pastor John Randall. May God richly bless you and strengthen you in your daily walk.

Join us next time as we continue our journey through the Bible. This program is brought to you by Calvary South OC and made possible through the support of our listeners.

This transcript is provided as a written companion to the original message and may contain inaccuracies or transcription errors. For complete context and clarity, please refer to the original audio recording. Time-sensitive references or promotional details may be outdated. This material is intended for personal use and informational purposes only.

Featured Offer

The Great Exchange: Finding Freedom in Surrender by Michelle Randall

We’re very excited to tell you about a newly revised book from Pastor John’s wife, Michelle Randall! It’s, “The Great Exchange: Finding Freedom in Surrender!” Michelle calls the journey of surrendering our will for God’s will, the Great Exchange! And with candor, she shares her own real-life experiences of learning to relinquish her will for God’s will. With relatable, practical, and applicable insights for today’s struggles of faith and fear, “The Great Exchange” will encourage, strengthen, and challenge you in a quest for complete surrender and a fervent pursuit after God. Be set free as you exchange your will for God’s will.

Past Episodes

Loading...

About A Daily Walk

John Randall is the Senior Pastor of Calvary South OC located in San Clemente CA. John has been serving in pastoral ministry for over 25 years and is the featured speaker on the Bible teaching radio program "A Daily Walk." He is known for his clear and relatable presentation of the Scriptures.

About John Randall

As a child, John’s family began attending Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa in 1974. It was there that he attended the elementary school, Jr. High, and graduated from Calvary Chapel High School. Following graduation he went on staff at Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa as a janitor. It was also at this time that he met his wife Michelle who was teaching at Calvary’s elementary school.

After four years on staff having served in children’s ministry, high school ministry and worship John went on staff at Calvary Chapel in Vista CA.

In 1997 the Randall’s set out on a venture of faith to the SouthEast of Florida where they planted their first church, Calvary Chapel of Brandon. After ten years of ministry in Florida the Lord called the Randall's back to Southern California where John currently pastors at Calvary South OC. John has been serving in pastoral ministry for over 25 years and is the featured speaker on the Bible teaching radio program "A Daily Walk." He is known for his clear and relate-able presentation of the Scriptures. John and his wife Michelle have four children.

Contact A Daily Walk with John Randall

Address

Calvary South OC

1311 Calle Batido

San Clemente CA 92673


Instagram

@johnprandall


Twitter

@PJRandall7

Phone Number

877-242-0828