Oneplace.com

The Narrow Path 10/02/2025

October 2, 2025
00:00

Enjoy this program with Steve Gregg from The Narrow Path Radio.

Announcer: Good afternoon, and welcome to The Narrow Path radio broadcast. My name is Steve Gregg, and we're live for an hour each weekday afternoon taking your calls. If you have questions about the Bible or about the Christian faith, feel free to join us. You can give me a call, and we'll talk about those questions. If you see things differently than the host or want to balance a comment, we can talk about that as well. You can call me about that too. The number is 844-484-5737. That's 844-484-5737.

Speaking of disagreements, I'm going to be having a debate with a gentleman named Dr. Michael Brown about the subject of modern Israel. Is modern Israel a fulfillment of biblical prophecy? There'll be not one debate, but three. These are live, face-to-face debates going to be in Dallas, Texas, or Fort Worth. It's not entirely clear which it is. The church that's invited us to do it there has two campuses, and one of them is bigger than the other. So, we're not sure how many people to expect. We will, of course, announce beforehand when we make a decision, but it'll be either in Dallas or Fort Worth at the campuses of Mercy Culture Church. One of them is much larger than the other.

So, we're not sure at this point which one it'll be, but we have information at our website so far. There will be three debates, and they will all be about modern-day Israel's status biblically. Friday night there'll be one, there'll be one Saturday morning, and I think one Saturday afternoon. So, it's a weekend affair. If you're interested in that, that's November 7th and 8th. Information about that is at our website, thenarrowpath.com.

Before that, much before that actually, this month, actually this coming week. Today is the 2nd, and it's going to be on the 9th, a week from today actually. I'll be beginning an itinerary in Oregon, and I'll be up there for almost two weeks teaching various places all over the place. So, if you're listening in Oregon, there's a good chance I'll be speaking somewhere near to where you are. If you want to find out about that and attend any of our meetings, you're welcome to do so. The information, as always, is at our website, thenarrowpath.com, under Announcements.

Whether you're interested in any of these Oregon meetings this month or the debate in Texas with Dr. Michael Brown next month, that information can be found at our website, thenarrowpath.com, under Announcements. Now, if you'd like to be on the show today, we have a few lines open. Two of them just filled up as I was speaking. We have one line open, and you can call me at 844-484-5737. Our first caller today is Eli in Payette, Idaho. Eli, welcome to The Narrow Path. Thanks for calling.

Eli: Hi. A little ways ago, I listened to a lecture by Dr. Greg Bahnsen, and he made a really good point that I was wondering if you could talk on. He said that if God foreknows the future, then God has fore-experienced the future. Is the future certain to happen? He's talking against our free will, which you probably have guessed. He also makes the point that God is aware of the contingency, but that doesn't change Him experiencing what is certain to happen and how that works against man's free will. So, I'm just wondering if you could talk on that.

Steve Gregg: Yeah. Well, far be it from me to pit myself against such a great intellect as Greg Bahnsen, but I would have to say I don't necessarily follow his reasoning there. Of course, Greg Bahnsen was a Calvinist, and Calvinists do believe that God not only foreknows but predestined and foreordained all things that will happen, including every sin, every righteous deed, every conversion, every defection from Christ, and everything that happens is inevitable. It's going to happen because God foreordained it, and God is sovereign, and nothing can happen apart from what He has foreordained. That's what Calvinists believe.

Now, if that is true, of course, it does eliminate free will. Some Calvinists try to retain, along with that doctrine, some semblance of free will. They sometimes say they believe in compatibilistic free will. Compatibilistic simply means a kind of free will that is compatible with this idea that God ordains everything that happens. Not all Calvinists would explain how those two things could be compatible, but on the face of it, it would seem to any logical thinker that if everything is determined by God inevitably and nothing can go against it, then all of us who are going to act out this script are doing so without having any real say in the matter. We don't have any real free will.

But Calvinists do make a hard point to answer, and that is that if you believe that even if you say God doesn't foreordain all things but only that He knows all things, if you believe that He foreknows everything that's going to happen, then isn't that the same thing as it being determined? Whether God intended to determine it or not, doesn't His knowing it determine it? Because how could He know something's going to happen unless it is inevitably going to happen? If there's any chance that it won't happen, because let's say we have a choice in the matter and we might choose differently, well, then how could He know for sure that it's going to happen? If He knows with certainty it's going to happen, then it is going to happen. And if He knows it in advance, then it's predetermined.

Now, some people, in order to get out of that conundrum, have adopted openness theology. Now, openness theology is the view that God, though He knows all things, future choices that are not yet made by moral beings are not things because they don't exist. They haven't been done yet. God knows everything that's going to happen in the universe. He knows everything that's going to happen at this moment. He knows everything that He intends to do and that He is going to do. But the only thing they would say is not available for Him to know is what we're going to do, what choices we're going to make.

Some people say that this compromises God's omniscience, and I guess it depends on how you would define omniscience. Although the Bible doesn't ever define omniscience for us, omniscience means knowing everything. But the openness theologians would say, well, God does know everything, but choices that haven't been made yet aren't things. They don't exist. They don't exist in any world at this point. They will exist when they happen, but they can happen one way or the other because we have free will and therefore they cannot be determined, and they can't be certainly known to happen.

Now, this is problematic, especially with reformed theology, but even with Arminian theology. Lots of Arminians would say, no, that's too compromising of God's foreknowledge, of God's omniscience, although it's very difficult to know for sure. The Bible doesn't use the word omniscience, by the way, but if it did as theologians use it, it's not clear whether omniscience would refer to things being known even though they don't exist. There are lots of things that don't exist in the universe, and we'd have to assume that God doesn't know of their existence since they don't exist. Now, if something came to exist in the future, like a free choice that hasn't been made yet by somebody like you or me, then God would certainly know it. He might even know it just before it's made or sometime before it's made, but they would say it doesn't exist, so He doesn't know it, just like He doesn't know about any pink unicorns on the moon. Why doesn't God know about those? He's omniscient. Well, because they don't exist, that's why. Omniscience doesn't mean He knows everything that doesn't exist. He would know that it doesn't exist.

Anyway, there's a deep philosophical question, and I don't embrace openness theology myself. I've always been Arminian, but I can certainly see the sense in an openness theology argument. As an Arminian, most Arminians would say God does know the future though He's not the one who determines it. Our choices determine what will happen to us. Some of these choices haven't been made yet, but they will be, and we're the ones who are going to make them. God's not making them for us, we'll make them. And so, in a sense, they are part of the future. And if God knows the future, He knows we're going to make those choices, though He doesn't ordain for us to do so nor take any responsibility for them.

We're going to do it. And so Him knowing we're going to do it might give us some comfort just in knowing that there's nothing outside the range of His knowledge, but I'm not sure what it changes in terms of realities that we live through. If God knows I'm going to make a free choice or if He doesn't know I'm going to make a free choice, I'm still going to make a free choice and life and history go on just as whether God had known it or not. So, it's more of a theoretical question: does God know these things before?

And if He does, of course, how does He know them? How does God know them? Now, the Calvinists like Greg Bahnsen would say, well, God knows the future because He's foreordained it. In other words, God's sovereignty has foreordained everything that's going to happen, which means, of course, He knows what's going to happen. It's going to happen exactly the way He preordained it to happen. Nothing can happen differently. And unless God foreordains it, they would say He can't really know whether it's going to happen or not.

Now, most Arminians would say, well, He might. He might have ways of knowing it's going to happen that we don't know about. We really are not on His level. We really don't know very much about how God's nature operates. How does He know anything? How does He know everything that's going on at this moment? Well, it's not really ever told to us. How can He be omnipresent? How can He be eternal? How can He have never begun? I don't know, but I believe those things about Him.

There's a lot of things about God that are just above my pay grade, including if He knows all future things, how He does. I don't know. So, it's not my problem. I don't have to know it. I just would say for me to place limits on what God can know because I can't imagine how He could know it is for me to suggest that I'm kind of on God's level in a way, in terms of understanding how things are possible and how things work. I don't. I'm not on His level.

Some people say, C.S. Lewis, for example, was one, but many Christians say that God lives in a realm outside of time, where everything, past, present, and future, is in the eternal now for Him. There is no actual future from His point of view because He's outside the realm of time. He knows the future and the past, what we call the future, and what we call the past, and what we call the present, they're all present to Him, and therefore He knows the future without in any sense causing it to be.

Well, I mean, that's a philosophical point that some have made. The Bible doesn't teach that anywhere, so we can't say that the Bible says that, but it's not impossible that that's true. Some people think God knows the future that we will do, the things we will do in the future, the same way He knew that Peter would deny Him three times before the cock crows. Now, I could say He knew that because He had absolute foreknowledge of the future. But a person who could argue, well, maybe He doesn't have absolute foreknowledge of the future in the sense that He's outside of time like some say, maybe He knew Peter would do that because He knew the trajectory of things, that He knew what Peter was like, He knew how much pressure Peter could stand without caving in.

He knew Peter better than Peter knew himself. And Peter felt he would die before he'd deny Christ, but Jesus knew him better than that. And He also knew there were going to be three opportunities that would be too much for Peter to overcome, just knowing Peter's limitations and so forth. And therefore He could predict that Peter would deny Him three times before the cock crows and then would repent after that. That's four moral choices that Peter hadn't made yet, and Jesus predicted them accurately.

So, some would say, well, Jesus could do that not because He was outside of time and could see the future that way, but because He knows all things and He knows what Peter's limits are. He knew what Peter was like. He knew what's going to happen. He could see the trajectory of things and look forward and see where things are going, just like a computer could foresee where, if you hit a cue ball into a bunch of billiard balls, once they start heading in motion, a computer could predict where they're all going to go. And God is better than a computer for that.

Now, that may be true. That may be true, and that's the way the openness people would explain Peter's being predicted to deny Christ three times. Jesus knew it because He knew Peter. But the point I would make is: suppose that is true. Suppose Jesus knew it just because He knew Peter very well and He knew everything that's going on and He could calculate perfectly what's going to go on. Yeah, but that was fulfilled within a few hours. Let's just say within eight or nine or ten hours of the prediction, these things happened.

But if Jesus could predict four moral choices that Peter had not yet made in the next, and that he would make in the next, let's say ten hours, could He have done the same thing on the same basis to predict what Peter would do the next 24 hours, or 48 hours, or 72 hours, or 72 days? I mean, where's the limits of this? If God can kind of calculate from present trajectories of things exactly what someone's going to do, well, how far out can He predict that? Who says that ten hours is the limit? Maybe there's no limit. Maybe He can do that all the way up to a thousand years from now.

So, I don't really know. All I can say is that to say that man has no free choice, only the illusion of free choice because everything's foreordained by God and therefore just playing out a script that we don't have any real choices about, it simply goes against everything the Bible teaches about personal responsibility. God blames people for making choices that they make. Obviously, He can't blame them if they're just doing what He foreordained they would inevitably do.

If you drop a rock from a building and it lands on someone's head, you don't blame the rock. The rock had no say in the matter. You have to blame the person who dropped the rock. And so, if we have nothing to say about what we do, there's no responsibility, and there can't really be any righteous judgment. The Bible everywhere assumes that people could do things differently than they actually end up doing them, which means their actions were not foreordained.

I think of Cain, for example, when he didn't offer the kind of sacrifice he should have and Abel did, and Cain was angry at Abel. This is in Genesis chapter 4. God said, Cain, why are you so upset? If you do well, you also will be accepted. Okay, here we go. If you do well, you will be accepted like Abel was. So Cain wasn't predestined to do the wrong thing? He could actually have done the right thing? He could have been accepted instead of being rejected? God seems to be saying that. If God isn't saying that, that's certainly the impression He's giving. And if He's just teasing, if He's teasing Cain, Cain really couldn't do anything different but God's acting as if he could and telling him he could, well, then God is, we can't trust much of anything God says if that's the way He talks about things. I think if we follow what God actually says about choice and responsibility throughout scripture, we have to assume man has responsibility because he has choice. Anyone's theology that rules that out, I'm just going to have to disagree with. All right, let's talk to Ron in Orange County, California. Hi, Ron, welcome.

Ron: Hello, Steve. I hope you're doing well today.

Steve Gregg: So far so good.

Ron: Okay, great. Great. I love your show and it's really good to talk to you again. I've got a question for you. It seems that you lean heavily towards the young earth position. Am I correct about that?

Steve Gregg: That would be my default leaning, yes.

Ron: Okay. So my question is this. On a scale of one to ten, and ten being the Bible's definitive that it leans towards a young earth, and one being it doesn't lean any way at all, which would kind of be where I would come from, where would you put that? And then I've got a follow-up question to that, which is this. I was listening to your lecture on the authority of scriptures, the science and the Bible part, and around the 40-minute mark, you use the terminology that people kind of are weaseling their way into some of these positions. I just wanted to see if you would still hold to that. So those are my two questions. Do you think the Bible's definitive on young versus old, and the second one, do you think that people who are, they're kind of making excuses for this, I guess? How would you answer that?

Steve Gregg: Well, I would say this. You said what, on a scale of one to ten or whatever, what do I think is the likelihood that the Bible is leaning toward young earth? I'm going to give it a five or a six. I think it's about 50/50. And what I mean by that is, if the Bible is intended to be, if Genesis 1 is intended to be taken literally, then I'd say it's about 100%. If Genesis 1 is literally telling us how things happened, I would say it's 100% young earth. If the Genesis 1 is written in some literary form which the readers were not intended to take literally, then all bets are off. We'd then have to ask, well, how were they supposed to take it?

Now, there are other ways to take things. I mean, there's many things in the Bible that are parables or metaphors or hyperboles, or there's even one case in the Bible of a fable where the trees went out looking to make a king for themselves. That's what we call a fable, that's in the ninth chapter of Judges. And there's apocalyptic literature and so forth. Now, I don't see Genesis 1 as belonging to any of those categories. Poetry's another one. I mean, there's lots of ways the Bible expresses truth besides literal narration.

But Genesis in general is a book of literal narration. Now, some might say, but Genesis 1 kind of stands out on its own, different from the rest of the book. Obviously, when we're starting talking about people by name and what they did, we've got the language of narration. But when we're talking about the creation of the universe and everything in it, this could be given to us in sort of an elaborate creation poem that isn't intended to be understood literally. I've heard that and I could see that as a possibility. I'm just not sure that I have a good enough reason to take it that way. Now, I would if I felt that every argument, scientific argument for the young earth, was invalid and that every argument for the old earth was valid.

This transcript is provided as a written companion to the original message and may contain inaccuracies or transcription errors. For complete context and clarity, please refer to the original audio recording. Time-sensitive references or promotional details may be outdated. This material is intended for personal use and informational purposes only.

Featured Offer

On the Believer’s use of Forcible Resistance

Question from a pastor: In light of Christ’s command to “turn the other cheek” and to “not resist the evil man”, is it inappropriate for believers to contemplate or exercise physical force in defense of our families against criminal aggressors? Over the course of more than three decades, I have weighed the biblical testimony concerning this topic and related questions and cannot claim even now to have the final and definitive answer for every situation. Individual commands of Scripture teach us how these principles are expressed in various life decisions, but in the absence of specific commands we must proceed upon principle, and the commands that do exist should be interpreted in the light of such principles. Download the eBook to read more!

About The Narrow Path

The Narrow Path is Steve's teaching ministry primarily to Christians. In part, it is a one-hour, call-in radio show. Christians call in with questions about what the Bible says on many topics and how certain passages can or cannot be interpreted. Occasionally, an atheist or agnostic or one of another faith calls in to inquire or raise objections. Steve takes all calls, including objections to what he has presented. It is an open forum with polite, respectful discussions. The object is for the host and the audience to learn together.


The ministry also has a website, a Bible-discussion forum, a Call-of-the-Week video, a YouTube channel, and a Facebook page. These contain Steve's verse-be-verse teachings through the entire Bible, topical lectures and articles, friendly debates with folks of other opinions, and much more. Please explore these hundreds of resources. They are all valuable, but they are all FREE. We have nothing to sell. "Freely you have received, freely give."


Steve is also available to teach and answer questions at church and home meetings. He has taught on every continent. If you would like to have him speak in your area, just organize a group, a place, and propose a date, or several, and e-mail Steve@TheNarrowPath.com.


The Narrow Path exists through the gifts of donors who appreciate these resources. We have no corporate sponsors and run no commercials on the radio or ads on the website. If you are blessed by these resources, we ask that you first pray for us, then tell your family and friends, then consider donating to help us stay "on the air". God faithfully provides through listeners.

About Steve Gregg

Steve has been teaching the Bible since he was 16 years old—49 years!  His interest is in what the Bible actually says and does not say.  He uses common sense and scholarship to interpret the passages.  He is acquainted with what commentators and denominations say, but not limited by denominational distinctives that divide the body of Christ.  While he is well read, he is free to be led by Scripture and the Holy Spirit.  For details, read his full biography.

When asked a question about a passage, Steve usually lists its several interpretations, gives the reasoning behind each, cross-examines each, and then tells his own conclusions and reasons.  He tries to teach how to read and reason about the Bible, not what to think.  Education, not indoctrination.

Steve has learned on his own.  He did not attend a seminary or Bible college, but he was awarded a Ph.D. for his work by Trinity College of the Bible and Theological Seminary in Evansville, Indiana.  He is the author of two books:

(1) All You Want to Know about Hell: Three Christian Views of God's Final Solution to the Problem of Sin

(2) Revelation: Four Views, Revised & Updated

Contact The Narrow Path with Steve Gregg

Mailing Address:
The Narrow Path
P.O. Box 1730
Temecula, CA 92593
To ask a question on-air: (Radio Program)
844-484-5737  2-3 PM Pacific Time