Oneplace.com

The Narrow Path 04/07/2026

April 7, 2026
00:00

Enjoy this program with Steve Gregg from The Narrow Path Radio.

Steve Gregg: Good afternoon and welcome to The Narrow Path radio broadcast. My name is Steve Gregg and we're live for an hour each weekday afternoon so that you can call in and we can talk in real time. If you have questions about the Bible or the Christian faith you'd like to raise for conversation over the air, if you see things differently from the host and want to discuss that over the air, feel free to give me a call. I'm looking at some open lines, so if you called right now you'd get right on.

The number is 844-484-5737. That's 844-484-5737. And really I don't have many announcements to make right now I don't think, so we'll just go directly to the phones and we'll talk to John in Kent, Washington. Hi John, welcome to The Narrow Path. Thanks for calling.

John: Yeah, hey Steve. Thanks for taking my call. I was wondering, Matthew 24 and the Olivet Discourse, it mentions the fact of Daniel and the prophet Daniel but it doesn't mention it in Luke's or Mark's Gospel and I was wondering why that was. And is Olivet Discourse and the abomination of desolation the same thing? And I'd like to hear your answer off the air. Thanks.

Steve Gregg: Okay, well, we're talking about what Jesus said when he was asked when the temple would be destroyed. He had, in Matthew 24 in the opening verses, Jesus made a prediction that the Jewish temple would be destroyed and that not one stone would be left standing on another. As his disciples and he moved out toward the east of the city onto the Mount of Olives, four of his disciples actually came to him privately. We're told in Mark chapter 13 that there were four of them that did: James and John and Peter and Andrew.

And they came and asked him when would this be, when would the temple be destroyed? Now we know the answer to that historically was the temple in fact was destroyed 40 years later by the Romans in AD 70. Now that's what Jesus is going to answer to them. They say when is it going to be and what sign will there be that it's about to take place? Well, this answer to this question is found in Matthew 24, it's found in Mark 13, and it's also found in Luke 21.

Now you're talking about the fact that in Matthew 24, which is in verse 15, Jesus said, "Therefore when you see the abomination of desolation spoken of by Daniel the prophet standing in the holy place (whoever reads let him understand), then let those who are in Judea flee to the mountains." You're saying that Jesus here mentions the prophecy of Daniel about the abomination of desolation. And yet Mark, you say doesn't, but actually Mark mentions it too.

Luke doesn't. Mark chapter 13 verse 14, which is the parallel, says, "But when you see the abomination of desolation spoken of by Daniel the prophet standing where it ought not (let the reader understand), then let those who are in Judea flee to the mountains." So same thing. He says his disciples will see the abomination of desolation and that's what Daniel spoke about, and then they're instructed to flee out of Jerusalem because the temple's about to be destroyed at that time.

But the abomination of desolation that's mentioned in Daniel is an obscure phrase, at least to anyone who's unfamiliar with Hebraisms. Abomination of desolation literally means something abominable which presages destruction or desolation of the temple. Now the abomination that causes desolation is the way the Septuagint renders it in Daniel. And so there's something that Jesus said they would see that would indicate that the destruction of the temple is near.

And in Luke—now by the way Luke was not writing to a Jewish person or Jewish audience, he's writing to a Greek man named Theophilus. And I think Luke was pretty sure that Theophilus wouldn't be able to make any sense out of the Hebraism "abomination of desolation." Unless you've heard biblical teaching on the subject, you probably can't make any sense of it either; it's a Hebrew expression. But Luke still recorded the same discourse that Jesus gave, but he paraphrased things that he thought that Theophilus would not be able to understand on his own.

So when he got to this very statement of Jesus where Matthew 24 and Mark 13 both use the expression "abomination of desolation spoken of by the prophet Daniel," that entire phraseology is replaced in Luke chapter 21 verse 20 when he said, "When you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies, then know that its desolation is near. Then let those in Judea flee to the mountains." You can see it's the same thing because in Matthew, Mark, and Luke it says, "When you see X, then flee to the mountains."

In Matthew and Mark it uses the Jewish expression that Jesus used, which is the abomination of desolation. Luke paraphrases that: "When you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies, know that its desolation is near." So he's still talking about the desolation of Jerusalem. He just removes the expression "abomination of desolation" and replaces it with "Jerusalem surrounded by armies," which of course were the Roman armies and they came and did destroy it just as Jesus predicted.

And then in all three of these Gospels, because they are parallel, shortly after that Jesus says, "This generation will not pass before all these things are fulfilled." So the disciples asked Jesus two questions. He had said that the temple would be destroyed as it in fact was 40 years later, but they didn't know when it would be and they said, "When will these things be and what sign will there be that it's about to take place?"

So the answer to the first of those questions—when will these things be—is in his statement, "This generation will not pass before all these things take place." So he gave them the time frame and he was correct of course as we would expect him to be. But then they'd also asked what sign will there be and he said, "Well, when you see the abomination of desolation or when you see Jerusalem surrounded by armies," the way Luke put it, "then know that its desolation is near."

So they could know the general time of fulfillment would be within their generation. And as far as specific indicators that it was about to take place, the sign would be the abomination of desolation. Which again, I don't know how his Jewish disciples understood that, but Luke, whom we take to be an inspired New Testament writer, understood that to be a reference to the Roman armies coming and that that would be the signal to them that it was about to take place.

So that's what we have there. Now what did Daniel say about the abomination of desolation? Well, Daniel mentions the abomination of desolation actually three different times, but it's not always the same one. For example, the first time you find it is in Daniel chapter 9 verse 27 when it's talk about the 70th week of Daniel and in the middle of verse 27 it says, "On the wing of abominations shall be one, that is one abomination, who makes desolate." That is an abomination that makes desolation or the abomination of desolation.

That's the first time it appears. Now this in Daniel 9 occurs after the Messiah has come and after the Messiah is put to death because the previous verse in Daniel 9:26 says, "After the 62 weeks Messiah shall be cut off," which means he'll die. So the death of the Messiah happens and shortly after that it says in verse 26 the people of the prince who is to come shall destroy the city and the sanctuary. Well, that happened. The Romans came, they destroyed the city Jerusalem and the sanctuary the temple just as was predicted here. And that was the abomination of desolation according to Daniel 9.

Now the term abomination of desolation occurs a couple of more times but in different connections. Because it says in Daniel chapter 11, two chapters later at verse 31, it says, "Forces shall be mustered by him," and this "him" in the context is Antiochus Epiphanes, a Syro-Greek oppressor of Israel in the second century BC, about 167-168 BC. This man was oppressing the Jews and this is who it's talking about. It says, "Forces shall be mustered by him, they shall defile the sanctuary fortress," meaning the temple. "Then they shall take away the daily sacrifices and place there the abomination of desolation."

Now that was fulfilled when Antiochus Epiphanes put an altar to Zeus in the Jewish temple and sacrificed a pig, a very unclean thing in the sight of the Jews, in the temple and it defiled the temple. And that was the abomination that made the temple desolate. But that's not the same one that Daniel 9 was talking about because Daniel 9 says it'll happen after the Messiah has come. Antiochus Epiphanes did this almost 200 years before the Messiah came. So there's two abominations of desolation that Daniel mentions.

Then later on in Daniel 12:11 it says, "From the time that the daily sacrifice is taken away and the abomination of desolation is set up, there should be 1,290 days." Now that's a very obscure passage, I'm not going to speculate about the days, but you see it's a third reference to the abomination of desolation in the book of Daniel. And it's not clear whether he's referring to the one that's found in chapter 9, which occurs after the Messiah has died, or the one that's referred to in chapter 11, which was set up by Antiochus Epiphanes.

I think it's the latter; the wording of it makes me think so. But when Jesus said in the Olivet Discourse, "When you see the abomination of desolation standing where it ought not be that was spoken of in Daniel," well, was he talking about Daniel 11, Daniel 12, or Daniel 9? It seems obvious it's Daniel 9. Because the abomination of desolation that was mentioned in Daniel 11, which was set up by Antiochus Epiphanes, was already in the past when Jesus was speaking, so he wouldn't be speaking of it in the future tense.

It was the abomination of desolation from Daniel 9:27 that he's referring to, the only one Daniel mentions that would be after the Messiah has come and died. So we have to say that the Olivet Discourse then and the abomination of desolation or the surrounding of Jerusalem by armies was fulfilled in AD 70. And so you were wondering if that was different than some other abomination of desolation.

I know a more popular teaching today is that there's something called the abomination of desolation that will happen in the end times. Now the Bible doesn't mention that one. But what they basically say is that in the end times there'll be a third Jewish temple built—another thing the Bible never mentions—but that this third Jewish temple will be defiled by a future Antichrist who will be a lot like Antiochus Epiphanes was in the second century BC, but this will be an end times figure who will also defile this future Jewish temple in Jerusalem by putting an idol of himself in the temple.

Now the Bible doesn't mention this anywhere. There's no mention of any idol of any Antichrist put in any temple in the end times. If someone says, "Well, doesn't it say in Revelation 13 that the second beast will make an image of the first beast and require everyone to worship it?" Yes, but there's no mention of Jerusalem, no mention of any temple. There's no mention of geography at all. So there's nothing there that says he's going to set an image in a temple. It just says there's going to be an image and this seems to be a global situation that everyone will be required to worship, but not a hint about a temple in Jerusalem there.

Now another place is in 2 Thessalonians 2 where it says that the man of lawlessness will sit in the temple of God claiming to be God. Well again, this doesn't mention anything about an image or an idol. This talks about a man sitting in a place; has nothing to do with an idol. So there's nothing in the Bible anywhere about an image of an Antichrist sitting in a Jewish temple. And by the way, when Paul used the term "temple of God" in 2 Thessalonians chapter 2, this is not the only place in the Bible that Paul uses that expression.

There are two other times Paul uses the expression "temple of God" and only two other times. The other two are in 1 Corinthians 3:16 and in 2 Corinthians 6:16. In both places Paul's speaking to the church of Corinth and says, "Do you not know that you are the temple of God?" So in Paul's thinking, the church is the temple of God, not the Jewish temple. Paul knew as well as we do that Jesus had abandoned the Jewish temple. He said, "Your house is left to you desolate. You'll never see me again unless you say 'blessed is he who comes in the name of the Lord.'"

So the Jewish temple was abandoned; it was abandoned to its enemies. That's why it was destroyed in 70 AD. And the only temple of God that has existed ever since the time that Jesus walked the earth is the body of Christ. And Paul referred to the church as the temple of God. So when he said the man of sin will sit in the temple of God, there's not a reason in the world to imagine that Paul was thinking of the Jewish temple. Nor is there anything in the Bible that predicts a future Jewish temple.

Now I realize what I've just said goes against what probably 90% of our listeners have heard taught, and I don't mean to be a contrarian, but I welcome you to bring up the scriptures that prove me wrong because I'm just interested in what's true. And therefore if you know of a scripture that says there's going to be a future Antichrist and he's going to set up his image in a future Jewish temple and that is somewhere in the Bible called the abomination of desolation, those are the things I'm saying are not the case in the Bible.

But if someone wants to bring it up, it's very easy to disprove me with simply a scripture that disproves what I just said. So feel free, I always welcome people who disagree with me to call in. Feel free to call in and show me what scripture you think contradicts my statement. And we do have a couple of lines open if you want to call. The number is 844-484-5737. That's 844-484-5737. Our next caller is Jonathan from North Las Vegas, Nevada. Hi Jonathan, welcome.

Jonathan: Hello Steve. I am a 54-year-old man, I've been divorced three times. My older three children are grown, I have a 12-year-old and a 15-year-old. I want you to balance or give me balanced comment on the Proverbs, 1 Corinthians 7:25-40. I know there's two Proverbs that say he who findeth a wife findeth a good thing, and I think Proverbs 19:14 says houses and riches are an inheritance from fathers, but a prudent wife is from the Lord. There's also numerous Proverbs that say it's better for a man to dwell on the corner of a roof than to share a house with a quarrelsome wife. I'm intimately acquainted with that scenario. I'm sure there's a few other Proverbs too. How would you balance that? And I realize 1 Corinthians 7:25-40 is, I'm assuming, for people kind of in my situation. Could you comment on how the Proverbs and how Paul's message to the Corinthians correlate with each other?

Steve Gregg: Well sure. Yeah, well Proverbs of course is making general statements of observation of wisdom and certainly everything that Solomon says can be seen to be true. Paul is not making general comments. He's speaking to a particular church at a particular time and he says in verse 26, "I suppose therefore that this is good," that is remaining single. In the context it talks about not getting married. That this is good because of the present distress, that it is good for a man to remain unmarried as I am, he says.

So in a situation where Paul's addressing what he talks about, a church facing "the present distress"—now no scholar that I know of can tell you what the present distress was in Corinth, but Paul was mindful of a circumstance in Corinth that made ordinary rules something to apply differently. And that was basically he goes on to argue that if you get married you're going to have the burdens of family life, which he thinks is a good thing.

But he also was glad that he didn't have the burdens of family life because he traveled and he was imprisoned a lot and things like that; it would have made it very hard to have a family or to attend to a family with his calling. And he's saying there are others who may be called as I am to just devote themselves wholly to serving God without the distractions of family life. And he says at times like these—and again we don't know what those times were specifically, we don't know enough of the circumstances—but the audience knew, they knew what their circumstances were.

He said in the present distress it might be good for more people to stay single is what he's saying and to avoid the hassles of family life. Now he's not contradicting what Solomon said, that a wife is a good thing to have. He's simply saying it may be a good thing to have a wife, but this timing may not be good. It may not be a really good time to move in that direction in your life, there may be a more convenient time in the future.

But Solomon's statement—he does say that he that finds a wife finds a good thing—is simply affirming what it says in Genesis chapter 1, that God made male and female and he blessed them and it said when he saw what he'd made it was very good. Having a wife, or at least let's just say the idea of a wife, is a good thing to have. If you don't have wives you don't have families. If you don't have families you don't have children. If you don't have children the human race doesn't last very long.

So it's a good thing, husbands and wives. Marriage is a good thing and God ordained it to be a good thing. Now Solomon also in some of the Proverbs mentions conditions. He says in one place he says a wise woman builds her house, but a foolish woman tears it down with her own hands. And by that he means the family. A good woman builds the family in cooperation with her husband. An evil woman or a foolish woman tears the family apart whether the husband's trying to make it work or not.

Many husbands, like yourself perhaps, have seen that. You try to save the family, you try to make it work, you've got a wife who is just not interested in the family working and they tear it down with their own choices and their own decisions. Solomon recognizes that. He also notes that a good wife is a wonderful thing. And so I think everyone would agree with that unless someone hasn't ever known a good wife or seen a good wife or know what it is. A good wife is a wonderful gift of God. Houses and lands are an inheritance of fathers, but a good wife is from the Lord.

And that makes it very clear that not all wives are good. When you have a good wife, that's a special blessing from God because many people have wives that aren't good and many women have husbands that aren't good. Marriages are not easy in themselves and they're not always a good match. People can very foolishly marry somebody that's going to be a headache to them and to their children and a curse to them ultimately. That's not what the Bible recommends of course.

The Bible assumes certain things about marriage too because it was written at a time when people, integrity was something that mattered to people. Most people would be ashamed to be known as a scoundrel, as a liar, as a sham, and one's integrity and one's character was of great value. It's a shame-based culture and if someone could show that you were a liar and a cheat, you endured shame and so forth. And so people didn't, they weren't as careless about keeping their promises as sometimes we are.

Because in our society people aren't ashamed if you lie and someone says you're a liar, you just say "who cares?" I made money off you or I got what I wanted from you, who cares I'm a liar? Now when you get married, you make promises. And in certain ages earlier than our own, people took those promises seriously and they wouldn't get divorced just because they had a hard time adjusting to married life. They were committed to being married, especially once they had children.

They wanted to have a home that was going to be safe and healthy for their children. So if they had a hard time getting along, at least Christian people, they wanted to work it out. And sometimes if they couldn't work it out to be happily married, they'd stay married anyway for the children or just to be honest people because after all, you do promise at the altar that you will stay with them and cherish them and nourish them. You say "but she doesn't nourish me or cherish me." Yeah, you didn't promise that she would nourish you, she promised that. You promised you'd nourish her.

So you can only keep your promise, you can't keep your spouse's promise. That's on them. Now unfortunately we have a lot of people in our society who couldn't care less about their integrity, couldn't care less about their character, and they couldn't care less about their promises. And therefore they'll divorce simply because they're not happy in the marriage. In a more mature and honest society, people who weren't happy in their marriage would say "what can I do to be happier in my marriage?"

Or their spouse who knew that they weren't happy in the marriage would think "what can I do to make my spouse happier?" In other words, most people knew they're going to stick it out unless they just want to make themselves a liar and turn their vows into shams. And so they wanted to be happy rather than unhappy if they could, so people would work on their marriages. We live in a time where people will work on their marriages for a while, but if it isn't easy enough a lot of them will just dump it and go looking for something better, which means they make themselves scoundrels.

Because if you promise you'll do a certain thing and the other person shapes their whole life around the assumption you're going to keep your promise, and then you betray them and say "sorry I don't care what I promise, I'm going to do what I want to do," that's a horrendous betrayal. That just shows a person has zero character. And if you have zero character no one should ever trust you again. But so many people have zero character and divorce their spouses for no good reason that people stop taking it seriously as something—they just figure, well, I guess you're about average.

Average isn't what God's looking for. God's looking for people who are faithful people who swear to their own hurt and don't change, the Bible says. So an honest Christian who's determined to please God will never divorce their spouse unless they are more or less forced to by their spouse's behavior, which can usually mean their spouse is cheating or their spouse has abandoned the marriage and won't come back. So you've had some bad wives. I don't know if you've been a good husband or not.

I'm going to give you the benefit of the doubt, but your wife might not think you were. I don't know what they think. All I can say is that if people are dedicated to Christ and married, they're first of all not going to be trying to make each other's lives miserable. Secondly, they're going to try to make a safe and permanent home for their children to be raised in and to be nurtured in Christ. Third, they're going to endure hardship together and grow closer together through it rather than become each other's rivals and enemies in a hard situation.

But there are women and men, but Solomon mentions there are women who tear down their house with their own hands. I have known a couple of those too and apparently you have too. What can I say? The Bible doesn't say marriage is always easy or that it always has good results, but marriage is a good thing because God made it. And because it's a good thing, we need to work hard to make ours as good as it can be for God's glory. Need to take a break, our website's thenarrowpath.com. I'll be back in 30 seconds. We have another half hour, don't go away.

Steve Gregg: Welcome back to The Narrow Path. My name is Steve Gregg and we're live for another half hour taking your calls. If you have questions about the Bible or the Christian faith or a disagreement with the host and want to call and talk about that, you are welcome here. Five days a week, Monday through Friday, we've been doing this show for 29 years. We did take a hiatus for about a year back in the early 2000s, but other than that we've been on steadily since 1997.

Five days a week, which is a lot of radio shows we've had and we're still doing it. So if you can't get on today, try tomorrow, we should be here still, Lord willing. But we do have several calls waiting that I hope we can get them all on before out of time. We have another half hour. Let's talk to Glenn in Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania. Glenn, welcome to The Narrow Path. Thanks for calling.

Glenn: Hi Steve. Question of the Passover. Jesus was on a cross, said truly truly you'll be in paradise with me tonight. And then two other scriptures, he spent three days in the heart of the earth, and "don't touch me because I haven't seen the Father yet." How are all three reconciled?

Steve Gregg: Well, I don't see those as so difficult, although what you're saying is Jesus spent three days in the tomb—or at least that's how he described it, three days and three nights. And yet the beginning of that three days he was on the cross and he told the thief "today you'll be with me in paradise," which suggests that he, Jesus, would go to paradise and so would that thief that very day. And so how could that be if he was dead for the next three days and then rose again?

And then the third scripture you're thinking of, Mary Magdalene I think in John chapter 20, when she first saw him after he rose, he didn't say "I haven't seen the Father yet." He said, "Do not hapto me." The Greek word is *hapto*, which means cling to me. It can mean touch, but in this context it means "don't cling to me because I have yet to ascend to the Father." In other words, I'm back but I'm not staying. I'm going to still yet ascend to the Father and I won't be here, so don't cling to me.

Don't insist on me being here present with you. I'm sure that she was very affectionate toward Jesus as we know. So when she saw him alive after she thought he was gone for good, she probably grabbed onto him. We know that later the same day some other women grabbed his feet when they saw him. They touched him; I don't know why Mary wouldn't. Now what you're suggesting is when Jesus said "touch me not"—this is how the King James renders it "touch me not, I have yet to ascend to my Father."

Some people think that, well, she couldn't touch him and yet people did a few minutes later in another situation. So it must be, they say, that he ascended to the Father after he saw her and then when he came back like almost immediately from the Father, the other women were allowed to touch him but she wasn't because he hadn't yet ascended to Father. That's not what he's saying. The King James says "touch me not." The word touch, the Greek word is *hapto*. And *hapto* has a variety of meanings, but one of its common meanings is to cling to.

And so I think even the New King James, which follows the King James very closely but not slavishly, I think even the New King James has it say "do not cling to me." I'm not looking at the passage right now but almost every new translation would say "don't cling to me" because that's the meaning in this context. He's saying "don't cling to me as if to never let me go. I'm going again. I'm going to ascend to my Father." Not today, not tomorrow. We know it happened 40 days later that he ascended to the Father.

He's predicting that. He's saying "I know that you thought I was going to be here forever and I was taken away from you when I was crucified. And now I'm back and you probably are determined to never let me be taken away from you again, but I'm going to be taken away from you again; I'm going to ascend to my Father yet." And so he's saying "don't cling to me," meaning don't become emotionally dependent on my presence here physically because I'm leaving again is basically what he's saying.

So not saying that it's wrong for her to touch him, but for her to try to hold onto him as if she's not going to let him go again. "Well, I am going again," is what he's saying. And that's how I understand his words in those places. As far as where paradise is, it would appear that paradise where he and that man were that very day was part of Sheol or Hades. And that's how the Jews used the term paradise in those days. Hades is where all the dead people went, in Jewish theology in Second Temple Judaism.

And Hades had two compartments; one of them was paradise or Abraham's bosom. The other was they called it Gehenna, but the point is that the righteous went to Abraham's bosom or paradise. They were in Hades, which is in their thinking under the ground, but it was not heaven. And he didn't go up to see God during that time, he was in Hades, he was in apparently paradise. So then of course he rose from the dead and 40 days later he did ascend to heaven.

So when he said to the man "today you'll be with me in paradise," I assume he told the truth, that they were both in paradise which was in Hades at that time. Then of course he rose from the dead and when he told Mary "don't cling to me because I'm going to eventually ascend to my Father," he's talking about her emotional attachment there. I mean she was probably physically holding onto him, but of course that was a physical demonstration of her emotional attachment.

He's saying "listen, you need to kind of let me go, I'm going to be going, I'm going again so don't hang onto me." Not saying that it's wrong for her to touch him, but for him to try to hold onto him.

Glenn: Was the thief part of the first fruits?

Steve Gregg: I don't know about first fruits. I thought when they came out of the ground he took the first fruits with them up to heaven with him. Well, the Bible doesn't say that clearly. You may be thinking of Ephesians 4 where it says that Jesus when he ascended he led a host of captives. Some people think that's referring to the righteous from paradise; they went into heaven with him when he ascended. That's one possible interpretation of that, so that could be.

But the man who died in faith, the thief who turned to Christ on the cross, that man simply after death joined others who had died in faith throughout the whole Old Testament period in paradise and Jesus apparently with them. And then when Jesus ascended, it is generally believed that yes they did ascend with him into heaven. This is not stated in unambiguous terms in scripture, but there are some statements in scripture that kind of would lean that way probably. Thank you for your call. Let's talk to James in Memphis, Tennessee. Hi James, welcome.

James: Yes, thank you for taking my call, Steve. In Saint John when Jesus said a man must be born again of water and of the spirit, what's your take on the water?

Steve Gregg: Well, many people think he's referring to being baptized here. I don't see anything in the context that would suggest this. It's a very common thing for Christians and actually the first place I heard this suggested was from the Mormons, but then I found out that lots of Christians think the same way about it. That when Jesus said, "a man"—he says in verse 5 of John 3, "Jesus answered, 'Most assuredly I say to you, unless one is born of water and the spirit, he cannot enter the kingdom of God.'"

For some reason, there's a number of Christians who have decided that "born" is a synonym for baptized. Now I don't know of anything in the Bible that equates baptism with being born, so I'm not sure why they would read it into this. He's talking about birth. He's talking about two kinds of birth. He first says a man has to be born again. The assumption is he's been born once already and he's got to be born again. And he doesn't explain initially what that second birth is.

But in verse 5 he says, well, a man has to have two births: he's got to be born of water and born of the spirit. So the second birth is being born of the spirit. The first birth is being born of water. Now what does that mean? Does it mean baptized? If it does, there's certainly no explanation in scripture that would suggest it. That is a tradition that apparently some groups have adopted, but if we're going to go exegetically and read the Bible for what it says and not what we try to make it say, there's not a hint here that he's got baptism in mind.

But what would be born of water then? Well, he contrasts that. That's the first birth is born of water. The second birth is being born of the spirit. Those are the two births he mentions here. The next verse, verse 6, he says, "That which is born of the flesh is flesh, and that which is born of the spirit is spirit." Now notice all through here he's talking about two different births. There's the one that Nicodemus already has, but then he has to be born again, so there's a second birth to be gone through.

In verse 5 he contrasts these two births. He calls the first one being born of water and the second one he calls being born of the spirit. In the next verse, 6, he also speaks of the second birth as being born of the spirit, but he speaks of the first birth there as being born of the flesh. So the spiritual birth is the second birth. The first birth is called in verse 5 "born of water" and in verse 6 "born of the flesh." Now born of the flesh simply means physically born, which seems to point in the direction of interpreting "born of water" to refer to physical birth.

A man has to have two births. He must be born of water and he's got to be born of the spirit. He's got to be born of the flesh, which is the initial birth, and born of the spirit as he said earlier. Now why would physical birth be referred to as being born of water? An answer can occur to us, although we don't know exactly if this is the right answer. We certainly know that in most cases, virtually every case, when a baby is born, it is preceded with the breaking of the waters.

And the coming of the waters indicate the baby's right behind. The birth has begun when the sac is broken. The baby's coming right out behind the water pretty much. So the idea is that the first birth is you're born through this watery birth, but then there's a different kind—and that's just natural birth. That's being born of the water, which verse 6 calls being born of the flesh. The other birth is being born of the spirit. Now just as being born of the water or born of the flesh, natural birth, is coming into a new world as a baby and starting a new life, so a person needs to have a spiritual rebirth in the sense that they need to come into the spiritual world with a new spiritual life as a spiritual baby.

They need to start all over in terms of their spiritual journey, their spiritual experience. So he's saying that everybody has been naturally born of course, but not everyone has had the second birth, not everyone has been born of the spirit. Now by the way, this statement and this contrast no doubt was particularly poignant because he was talking to Nicodemus, a well-pedigreed Jewish leader. And the Jews believed that they were God's special people because of their natural birth.

They were born descended from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob and they felt like that made them different and better than others and God's special favorites. And when Jesus said, "No, I don't care who your ancestors are, even if you're descended from Abraham, Isaac, and Jacob, that's nothing more than fleshly descent. And whatever is born of the flesh is still flesh. So it doesn't matter who your fleshly ancestors were, you're not different than anyone else who's flesh due to that birth. If you want to be God's people, if you want to be in God's family, if you want to be a child of God, you've got to have something more than your natural pedigree. You've got to have a spiritual experience, a spiritual rebirth."

And that's what Nicodemus is being told. And of course Christians ever since have recognized that that's true. You're not a Christian because you have Christian parents or ancestors; you're a Christian because you have experienced a spiritual regeneration where as Paul put it, we've passed from death unto life. A new life has started in the spiritual realm. We have spiritual fruit produced in our lives, we have spiritual gifts given to us, we have a spiritual life that's eternal in nature and so forth. So it's coming into a new realm, the spiritual realm.

And this happens when we put our faith in Christ. We know this because even after Jesus explained this to him, the man said, "Well, how can these things be?" In verse 9 Nicodemus answered "How can these things be?" That's "how can a man be born spiritually?" Fortunately Jesus answered that. In verse 10 he said, "Are you a teacher of Israel, the teacher of Israel, and you don't know these things? Most assuredly I say to you we speak"—I think he means John the Baptist and himself probably—"what we know and testify what we've seen and you," meaning the Jewish leaders, "do not receive our witness."

He said, "If I've told you earthly things and you do not believe, how will you believe if I tell you heavenly things?" Now here's how he answers the question "how can these things be?" verse 14. Jesus said, "And as Moses lifted up the serpent in the wilderness, even so must the son of man be lifted up," and that means on the cross, "that whoever believes in him should not perish but have eternal life." Now when you're born again, you're born into eternal life. Well, how do you do that? Well, by believing in him.

Just like when Moses raised up the serpent in God's instructions, a bronze serpent, and the Jews who were dying of snakebite, if they looked at the serpent they'd be healed. Jesus said, "Well, I'm going to be lifted up too just like that serpent was on a pole, and it's not people looking at me but whoever believes in me will not die but have everlasting life." That is they'll be born into this eternal second birth. And so that's what he's talking about there.

If somebody wants to say that "born of water and born of the spirit" refers to baptism in water and baptism in the spirit, obviously I can't stop them, but I don't think that that's suggested anywhere in the text. And I think if you follow the train of thought from beginning to end, it just means that you have to have a spiritual rebirth which happens when you repent and put your faith in Christ and become his disciple, then he gives you his spirit and you're born or regenerated of the spirit of God. All right. Let's talk next to, let's see who's been here longest. We only have a little bit of time. Gerald in Little Rock, Arkansas is next. Hi Gerald, welcome.

Gerald: Hey, how you doing? I really like your show. I just wanted to say something about in the Greek and Hebrew original writings or whatever before they were put in the King James. I guess it was added, there was no punctuation or anything like that. Is that correct?

Steve Gregg: Well, I understand that's true of the Greek in the New Testament that there's no punctuation. I don't know much about the punctuation of the Hebrew; you may be right, it may be that there was none.

Gerald: Well, the reason I bring it up is because the way I understand it whenever it says today you shall be with me in the kingdom, I think the comma's in the wrong place that the scribes put there. I think he was just saying today, I'm just telling you today, you know, while we're both here looking helpless or whatever, you will be with me in the kingdom. He was assuring him.

Steve Gregg: I understand. I mean this is the Seventh-day Adventist position. Did I nail it? Okay, gotcha. Okay, well let me tell you, let me explain for people because we only have a few minutes what your position is. And I'm not going to refute it, I'm just going to say this is the position that you guys hold. And that is that when Jesus actually said, "Verily, verily, I say unto you today you will be with me in paradise." He's speaking to the thief on the cross. There is no punctuation in the Greek, so there is a comma in our English translation, but the comma could possibly be moved.

We have it this way: "Verily, verily, I say unto you, comma, today you will be with me in paradise." So it sounds like he's saying that very day they will be together in paradise because the comma is where it is. Now the Seventh-day Adventists say "Well wait, the comma could be moved because it's not in the Greek. He could be saying 'Verily, verily, I say unto you today, comma, you will be with me in paradise.'" So that Jesus would be saying the "today" refers to when he's saying it, not when they will be in paradise.

So "I say unto you today, comma, you will be with me in paradise," but not meaning immediately. Someday we'll all be in paradise together and that would be all he's affirming. Now technically it is possible to move the comma there and it would have that very implication. So I'm not going to refute that. My own thought is that that is not as likely in my mind as it is probably in yours, but Jesus often introduced a statement by saying "Verily, verily, I say unto you." It's a fairly common way to introduce a statement of Jesus.

In no other case did he say "Verily, verily, I say unto you today," and then make his statement. In other words, adding the word today to the introductory "Verily, verily, I say unto you," I don't think we have another case of it. And so it makes it seem less likely to me that he's adding that word to the introductory statement there. But it's not impossible, so you could be correct. Thank you for your call.

You've been listening to The Narrow Path. We are listener-supported. If you'd like to write to us, the address is The Narrow Path, PO Box 1730, Temecula, California 92593. Our website's thenarrowpath.com. Thanks for joining us.

This transcript is provided as a written companion to the original message and may contain inaccuracies or transcription errors. For complete context and clarity, please refer to the original audio recording. Time-sensitive references or promotional details may be outdated. This material is intended for personal use and informational purposes only.

Featured Offer

On the Believer’s use of Forcible Resistance

Question from a pastor: In light of Christ’s command to “turn the other cheek” and to “not resist the evil man”, is it inappropriate for believers to contemplate or exercise physical force in defense of our families against criminal aggressors? Over the course of more than three decades, I have weighed the biblical testimony concerning this topic and related questions and cannot claim even now to have the final and definitive answer for every situation. Individual commands of Scripture teach us how these principles are expressed in various life decisions, but in the absence of specific commands we must proceed upon principle, and the commands that do exist should be interpreted in the light of such principles. Download the eBook to read more!

About The Narrow Path

The Narrow Path is Steve's teaching ministry primarily to Christians. In part, it is a one-hour, call-in radio show. Christians call in with questions about what the Bible says on many topics and how certain passages can or cannot be interpreted. Occasionally, an atheist or agnostic or one of another faith calls in to inquire or raise objections. Steve takes all calls, including objections to what he has presented. It is an open forum with polite, respectful discussions. The object is for the host and the audience to learn together.


The ministry also has a website, a Bible-discussion forum, a Call-of-the-Week video, a YouTube channel, and a Facebook page. These contain Steve's verse-be-verse teachings through the entire Bible, topical lectures and articles, friendly debates with folks of other opinions, and much more. Please explore these hundreds of resources. They are all valuable, but they are all FREE. We have nothing to sell. "Freely you have received, freely give."


Steve is also available to teach and answer questions at church and home meetings. He has taught on every continent. If you would like to have him speak in your area, just organize a group, a place, and propose a date, or several, and e-mail Steve@TheNarrowPath.com.


The Narrow Path exists through the gifts of donors who appreciate these resources. We have no corporate sponsors and run no commercials on the radio or ads on the website. If you are blessed by these resources, we ask that you first pray for us, then tell your family and friends, then consider donating to help us stay "on the air". God faithfully provides through listeners.

About Steve Gregg

Steve has been teaching the Bible since he was 16 years old—49 years!  His interest is in what the Bible actually says and does not say.  He uses common sense and scholarship to interpret the passages.  He is acquainted with what commentators and denominations say, but not limited by denominational distinctives that divide the body of Christ.  While he is well read, he is free to be led by Scripture and the Holy Spirit.  For details, read his full biography.

When asked a question about a passage, Steve usually lists its several interpretations, gives the reasoning behind each, cross-examines each, and then tells his own conclusions and reasons.  He tries to teach how to read and reason about the Bible, not what to think.  Education, not indoctrination.

Steve has learned on his own.  He did not attend a seminary or Bible college, but he was awarded a Ph.D. for his work by Trinity College of the Bible and Theological Seminary in Evansville, Indiana.  He is the author of two books:

(1) All You Want to Know about Hell: Three Christian Views of God's Final Solution to the Problem of Sin

(2) Revelation: Four Views, Revised & Updated

Contact The Narrow Path with Steve Gregg

Mailing Address:
The Narrow Path
P.O. Box 1730
Temecula, CA 92593
To ask a question on-air: (Radio Program)
844-484-5737  2-3 PM Pacific Time