Understanding God's Plan for Israel and Gentiles
Teaching The Word with Dr. Lawrence Taylor Episode 26
Announcer: Hello and welcome to Teaching the Word with Dr. Lawrence Taylor. Each and every week, Dr. Taylor will be sharing a relevant message from the scriptures designed to inform and instruct us in the ways of our God. Dr. Taylor has been the pastor of Kenilworth Baptist Church in the Midwood section of Brooklyn for the past 22 years. He brings a wealth of experience to each broadcast, having been a New York City public schools teacher and a theology professor. Stay tuned to the end of the broadcast to find out how to stream today's message. Now, here's Dr. Taylor.
Dr. Lawrence Taylor: Hello everyone. My name is Lawrence Taylor, and this is Teaching the Word with Dr. Lawrence Taylor. I'm so glad that you can join us today. I pray that you've been blessed by this ministry, and if so, will you please contact us by going to my website, lawrenceTaylorministry.com or.org, and just type or hit contact and leave a message. Also, if you're interested in past episodes, you can go to that website and you can get all the episodes of Teaching the Word with Dr. Lawrence Taylor. And there are other messages also on the website. Today we will examine Romans chapter 11, verses 13 to 24. This portion is fraught with controversy among New Testament scholars.
Some argue that Paul was promoting a rudimentary replacement theology. That is, God removed Israel from its position of privilege and replaced it with the church, and all of those promises that were made in the Old Testament to Israel have now been transferred to the church. Such an idea is expressed in John Calvin's commentary on Romans. This notion is widely accepted in the church today. New Testament scholar Mark Nanos rejects this view and characterizes it as anti-Semitic. Nanos himself, being Jewish and a New Testament scholar, rejects this view and says it is a misreading of Paul, especially in Romans chapter 11.
The scholar engages in a, I think, a laborious exegetical exercise to prove that translators have misread the text of Romans 11 because they view Paul as a Christian writer. He says they should view him not as a Christian, but a Jew. And as a Jew, his objective was to get his Gentile congregants to live a righteous life according to the spirit of the Torah. The crux of Nanos's argument is found in Romans chapter 11, verses 16 to 24. Needless to say, I disagree with this argument. While I do not support replacement theology, I think what Nanos does is read into the text something that the writer did not intend.
Now, Nanos correctly notes how anti-Semitism, anti-Jewish bias has tainted the perspective of New Testament scholarship. However, Nanos' approach appears to be an overcompensation that results in just, as I said, reading too much in the text. In Romans 11, verses 13 and 14, the Apostle Paul wrote, But I am speaking to you Gentiles in as much then as I am an apostle to Gentiles. I magnify my ministry if somehow I might move to jealousy my fellow countrymen to save some of them. The apostle calls special attention to this section by mentioning the office that God called him to. He wanted his readers to know that he took his ministry serious, and the call of apostleship to the Gentiles was something that he praised God about.
We should all learn a lesson from this, and that is when God calls us, this is not something to be taken lightly. we should not play around with this. We should recognize that this is serious. The gravity of this call can mean life or death. That is life, eternal life or eternal damnation. And so therefore, this is the highest calling in the universe. So the apostle understood this, and the apostle believed that God was going to use the conversion of Gentiles to the faith as a means to reach Jews. Let's note verse 15, quote, for if their rejection is the reconciliation of the world, what will their acceptance be but life from the dead?
This oscillation moving back and forth, salvation to the Jew, then to the Gentile, and back to the Jew is a display of the wisdom of God. Anos does not mention the Greek word for rejection in verse 15. Now that Greek word is apobole, apobole. Now let me spell that for you. That's A-P-O-B-O-L-E, and it means to cast away, to throw away. While it is true that the apostle wrote in verse 11 that Israel had not fallen, he does acknowledge they did stumble. There doesn't seem to be any other way to understand this scenario, except that Israel has been temporarily severed from God. Note how Israel's future is described at the end of verse 15, quote, life from the dead.
This implies that at the present time, Israel is dead. Now note that in order for them to be resurrected, you first have to be dead. That's why he says life from the dead. This is another point that Nanos does not elaborate on. Paul uses both a baking and horticultural analogy in verse 16 to prove that this severance is temporary. Quote, if the first piece of dough is holy, the lump also, and if the root is holy, the branches are too. The point of the analogy is simply this: if the Jewish forefathers were holy, so are the descendants. If they were unholy, so would the descendants be. God's promise was not just to the original generation, but to the entire progeny, all the descendants.
Therefore, even in their stumbling state that they're in, he says one day they will come to life. Well, what does Paul mean when he wrote in verse 11, but if some of the branches were broken off? It is at this point that Mark Nanos engages in eisegesis, reading into the text, and that's in verse 15. Nanos argues that the Greek word translated broken off, which is only one word in Greek, ekkalo, E-K-K-L-O, ekkalo, means to injure or crush, not to break off. If the word means to injure or crush and not to sever, the branches are not cut off. This ekkalo Paul uses in verses 17, I'm sorry, he uses the word branches in verses 17, 18, 19, and 21, and 24.
And these branches represent Israel. And what he's saying is that the branches are still there. They have not been broken off. There's been no severance. So, therefore, Paul was not really, Nanos argues, a Christian, since he never uses the word. He was a Jew attempting to get his congregants to live according to the principles of the Torah. Well, as I said, this is a stretch. But the major problem with this polemic is that it ignores the meaning of words. If you examine the text carefully, you will see that Paul is crafting an argument for Israel's future salvation in light of their rejection of the Messiah.
One is compelled, if you accept this argument that Nanos lays out, to ascribe new meaning to words like rejection in verse 15, not spare in verse 21, cut off in verse 22. So let's concede that the word broken off does not mean literally to break off, but to injure or to crush. These other words certainly indicate a severance. So therefore, the translators are correct to translate this Greek word ekalo to mean broken off. Gentiles in verse 17 are described in this horticultural analogy as a wild olive tree grafted into the tree. But if some of the branches were broken off, and you being a wild olive were grafted in among them and became a partner with them of the rich root of the olive tree.
Verse 17 tells us that the entire nation did not reject. Paul is an example of that. The Judean churches, the church in Jerusalem, those are all examples that not all the branches were broken off. But let's face it, most of Israel rejected the Messiah. Now, today in the church, if a Jewish person accepts Christ, he or she is part of the church. Paul wrote in Galatians chapter 3 verse 23, there is neither Jew nor Greek, there is neither slave or free. There is neither male nor female, for you are all one in Christ. So therefore, a Jewish person who accepts Christ is part of the body of Christ.
There are no distinctions made today. However, after the church age is completed and the Messiah returns, the nation of Israel will be saved. God gives the Gentiles an admonition in verses 18 to 21, quote, Do not be arrogant towards the branches, but if you are arrogant, remember that it is not you who supports the root, but the root supports you. You will say then, branches were broken off so that I might be grafted in. Quite right, they were broken off for their unbelief, but you stand by your faith. Do not be conceited, but fear. But if God did not spare the natural branches, he will not spare you either.
End of quote. Many who subscribe to the Arminian doctrine that one can lose their salvation use this text, but that's a misreading. In this text, Paul is talking about the nation of Israel. He writes about the Gentiles, the ethnoi or the, yeah, ethnoi, that's E-T-H-N-O-I, that's nations or Gentiles, because that's what the word Gentiles means, nations. and he distinguishes them from Israel. But there is one single nation that he's concerned with, and it's not an individual that he's talking about that has been severed, but he's talking about the nation of Israel. Listen, you may say, well, nations are made up of individuals there.
Yeah, that's absolutely true, but let's look at how unique Israel is. The promise that one day God will save the nation of Israel is not given to any other nation in the world. There is no promise in the Bible that one day God will save every American. There is no promise in the Bible that one day God will save every Nigerian, that he will save every Cuban. No such promise. That promise is only given to one nation, that is the nation of Israel. So Paul tells his predominantly Gentile congregation to don't be arrogant. Don't express anti-Semitic sentiments against the nation of Israel. They still have special status in the sight of God.
The reason why they were severed was because of unbelief. He tells the Gentile Christians in verse 21 that the same thing could happen to them. Unbelief in God's Messiah was the sole grounds for this severance. The apostle wrote in verse 24, but if you were cut off for what is by nature a wild olive tree and were grafted contrary to nature into a cultivated olive tree, how much will these who are the natural branches be grafted into their own olive tree. The promise is that it's going to happen. Now note, he says one day Israel will be saved. Unfortunately, we view unbelief in God's Messiah as if it were some inconsequential thing.
Every day we engage in social intercourse with the unsaved, as we should, whether friends or family, and we pretend as if their unbelief was some mere triviality. However, the unbeliever has been placed by God in a category of wrath. He is a wrath-bound sinner, doomed to face the eternal judge of the universe. No amount of social favor that we heap on them will help in the day of wrath. Our affections for them, whether family or friend, will do them no good when they stand before the great white throne judgment. On that day of judgment, their cry will be, hide us from the presence of him who sits on the throne and from the wrath of the Lamb, for the great day of their wrath has come, and who is able to stand?
Unbelief in the divine provision that God made for our sins besmirches the impeccable character of the infinite God of the universe. Unbelief says that God is not good enough to provide a propitiatory sacrifice that can atone for my sins. I am capable of standing, so the unbeliever believes, under the burden and weight of my own transgressions and being judged. Unbelief dares God to give us what we deserve. God offers us grace because he knows that it's only by grace that we can enter into his presence. But the human cry is, no, we don't want grace. We want human merit instead. Unbelief belittles the grace of God.
It does despite to his mercy. It ridicules his holy character and impunes his integrity. It castigates his loving kindness. Hopeless and helpless sinners, in their own feeble attempts, try to elevate themselves to the position of the eternal judge. Their self-exonerations are worthless. God says, I am judge. Unrepentant sinners proclaim their innocence, but God says, you are guilty. Let us examine the record together about the effects of unbelief. Unbelief condemned the holiest nation in human history into a state of hard-heartedness and blindness. The unbelief of Israel changed its privileged standing to a status of castaways.
Those who had been granted the greatest prerogatives on the planet have now become the objects of divine rejection. Unbelief is not a mere triviality in the sight of God. However, God in his inestimable wisdom, used Israel's unbelief to bring salvation to unworthy, sinful, heathen, hell-bound idol worshippers. Gentiles enslaved to demons and their own sinful passions, God has rescued with his mighty hand. The Almighty raised them up from their lowly estate by giving them the status of sons of God. One day, witnessing to an unsaved person, he said to me, "Who do you think you are?" I told him without any reservations, "I'm a blood-bought, Holy Ghost-filled, sanctified, hallelujah-shouting, born-again, heaven-bound, on fire, made up my mind, won't turn back, satisfied by and bearing the name of Jesus.
God the Father is my creator, Jesus my redeemer, the Holy Ghost my companion, and I'm on my way to heaven and the trip is free and I don't have to get charged for it and I won't get lost on the way because Jesus paid the ticket and he's my guide all the way. I remember God made a promise to me that as a pastor, I would have to work. That is, I would have to work a secular job and that he would provide the job, and he did. He provided the job as a school teacher. Well, one day that job was in jeopardy because a superintendent, not a principal, not an assistant principal, but a superintendent did not like me.
He just had it out for me. When he came to the school to visit, he spoke to the principal and my supervisor, the assistant principal, and said, I'm going to get that guy. No one understood why. He just didn't like me. And so one day he told the school he was coming in to observe the art department. And so everybody in the art department prepared. Now, I was in the history department, social studies department, but he was coming in, he told them to observe, he's coming in to observe the art department. He had no such plan. His plan was to come in, go into my classroom, catch me off guard. And that's what he planned to do.
And you know what? It didn't matter whether I had a bad lesson or whether the lesson was sterling, outstanding. He was going to get me. But man makes his plans, but God makes his plans. And so when he came in, the art department was ready, and as they began to walk down the hallway with the principal, he says, I changed my mind. I'm not going to go to the art department. I'm going to the history department, and I want you to take me to Taylor's class. Everybody was thrown off by it. Walked into my classroom, but little did he know that that day I had been called to jury duty. In fact, I wasn't just on jury duty, I had to serve for an entire month on jury duty.
And so when he walked in, he saw a substitute and he was steaming mad. But he had his plans, but God had his plans. So I'm letting you know there is nothing like being favored by God. Amen.
Announcer: Thank you for listening to today's program. This broadcast is an extension of the ministry of Dr. Lawrence Taylor and the Kenilworth Baptist Church. To stream today's message, please go to lawrenceTaylorministry.com and click on Lawrence Taylor Ministry/Message. Please join us again next week at the same time for Teaching the Word with Dr. Lawrence Taylor.
Featured Offer
Do you have a prayer on your heart? You can send us a request for anything that might be troubling you, or for someone else.Take a moment now to send us your prayer request.
Past Episodes
Featured Offer
Do you have a prayer on your heart? You can send us a request for anything that might be troubling you, or for someone else.Take a moment now to send us your prayer request.
About Lawrence Taylor Ministry
The primary objective of this ministry is to give both a practical and exegetical interpretation of Scripture. The interpretation of Scripture should never be based on a creed or denominational biases. We will let the word of God speak for itself. Therefore, this ministry is not associated with any particular Church. We love God’s Church and believe that it is the obligation of all of God’s people to attend a Biblically sound local assembly. However, many people study the Bible through the filtered lens of their denomination. This ministry will be free of these kinds of preconceptions. The only presumption that we make is that the Bible is divinely inspired, inerrant, and infallible.
About Dr. Lawrence Taylor
Dr. Lawrence Taylor has been in the teaching ministry for almost 40 years. He received a B.A. degree from Philadelphia College of the Bible, a Master of Theology and a Masters of Sacred Theology from General Theological Seminary of the Episcopal Church. His Masters of Sacred Theology in the New Testament was done at Union Theological Seminary under the late New Testament scholar, Robin Scroggs. He also received a Doctor of Ministry from New York Theological Seminary. Prior to his studies at Philadelphia College of the Bible, he studied history at Brooklyn College with a minor in Classical Greek. The professors at Brooklyn College also allowed him to study the Greek of the Church Fathers, especially the works of Athanasius. His studies afforded him the opportunity to translate from Greek to English some of the works of Athanasius, especially the long sections on the Arian Controversy.
He has been at New York School of the Bible for 38 years, teaching a variety of Biblical and ministry subjects. I taught New Testament Greek at New York Divinity School and Seminary of the East. He has served as Pastor of Kenilworth Baptist Church since 1997 to the present. His ministry has been a teaching ministry and this new initiative (LTM) will help him reach more people with the word of God.
Contact Lawrence Taylor Ministry with Dr. Lawrence Taylor
Facebook:
https://www.facebook.com/Lawrencetaylorministry/
YouTube: