Leaving Pro-Gay Theology for True Faith
It’s been said that secret sins often lead to bondage. Joe Dallas shares his testimony of embracing homosexuality, even as a Christian, and how the Lord, and a supportive church family, helped him find forgiveness and the power to change.
Jim Daly: Hey Jim Daly here. If you like the Focus on the Family broadcast and haven't grown tired of this voice just yet, you'll love my Refocus podcast. On Refocus, I take a deeper dive with a respected thinker on different aspects of culture. I ask those hard questions that maybe they don't get that often, and I don't shy away from challenging topics to help you share God's grace, truth, and love with others.
So listen to Refocus with Jim Daly on your favorite streaming app today.
Guest (Female): The following program is sponsored by Focus on the Family and is supported by the prayers and financial gifts of wonderful friends like you.
John Fuller: This is John Fuller and please remember to let us know how you're listening to these programs, on a podcast app or website.
Guest (Male): The secret temptation you refuse to bring to light eventually becomes the secret sin you begin to make peace with, which eventually becomes the bondage which derails your life.
John Fuller: Quite an insight from Joe Dallas and you'll hear more from him today about how he conquered his particular secret temptation.
Jim Daly: Welcome to Focus on the Family with Jim Daly, I'm John Fuller.
Jim Daly: Well, what Joe said right there, uh, secret sins do lead to bondage and that's the essence of his story. Joe's an author, podcaster, and conference speaker and I know you'll be captivated by what he has to share.
John Fuller: And if you have young children nearby, you might want to use earbuds or listen later through our app. With that, here's Joe Dallas speaking at Central Assembly in Springfield, Missouri, on Focus on the Family with Jim Daly.
Joe Dallas: It began in 1971, when I was a 16-year-old junior in high school. And by that time in my life, unfortunately having been routinely molested by a number of men as a boy, growing up terribly confused, then realizing my sexual confusion was leading me towards interactions with grown men.
I had begun seeing adult men for secret sexual liaisons. Of course, at that time, 1971, you could get yourself killed if you declared yourself openly gay. So this was a secret part of my life. On the one hand, I felt such a discomfort with that that I was on a regular basis dosing myself with LSD and marijuana and cocaine.
But on the other hand, I was finding it oddly liberating to say, "This is who I am. I am gay. I embrace this. I am determined not to hate myself for this any longer."
And in that conflict, part of me saying no, part of me saying yes, I met a lovely classmate who asked me to a backwards dance. That's one of those dances where the girls ask the guys. And she was one of our homecoming princesses, a beautiful young lady, and I was very flattered and delighted to accept. We went out, had a wonderful time. I dropped her off and I said, "You know, I would love to see you again."
And she said, "That's great because I'd like to take you to church." That Sunday we drove from my hometown, Long Beach, California, out to Costa Mesa, California, to this little place called Calvary Chapel. A tiny church which was bursting at the seams with scores of newly born-again hippies who were on fire and not at all shy about talking about it.
To walk into that place was to feel something tangible. As a non-believer who knew nothing about the Father, the Son, or the Holy Spirit, I felt the presence of all three. I didn't know what it was, but it was like a wall of something that hit me.
And that was the first time I ever heard the Gospel clearly presented. And the impact was almost unbearable. I came under conviction that would last for weeks because I knew what it was going to require. I was just now embracing being a gay man and now here comes this conviction that I am going to take up my cross and say no to that.
And after going back and forth on it, finally, in the middle of the week at school, I snuck off school grounds, went to a little park across the street, and knelt under a tree and said, "Yes. Yes, I will receive your grace. I want to be born again. Please forgive me and take me." And oh, what a time that was.
But there was a problem. And I say this because I know, I know to this day there are many people in the church who are in the same position I was in. I had been born again. I had been filled with the Spirit. I loved the Lord, but I had temptations. And I thought the presence of those temptations meant there was something foundationally wrong with me.
And I felt that especially because, let's face it, in 1971, nobody was doing what we're doing this morning. Nobody was talking about this openly within the church. And while I heard people testifying about overcoming drug abuse, cultic experiences, violent backgrounds, I never heard a story of somebody dealing with this, which only reinforced my idea that I'm still a freak.
I'm still an abomination. I still don't fit in. I'm still on the outside. If these people knew what temptations I have, not behaviors. I had repented. And I was living a sanctified life. I in no way gave in to the temptations towards homosexuality, but I thought the presence of those temptations was an indicator that I was fundamentally defective.
And because I kept that a secret, I think you know where this is going. The secret temptation you refuse to bring to light eventually becomes the secret sin you begin to make peace with, which eventually becomes the bondage which derails your life.
And by 1978, the derailing happened. When I said very plainly to myself and to God, "I am tired. I want all these feelings to go away. I'm mad at You for not making them all go away. I'm mad at the church for not understanding people who have these particular temptations. I'm mad at, well, I mean, I was mad at everybody but President Nixon, and I wasn't crazy about him either."
So I said something very dangerous to say, "I will." Because in that moment I said, "I give myself permission. I am tired of trying to resist these feelings. I know that they are wrong. And you know what? I don't care anymore. I will give myself permission to indulge."
And that was the day I stepped into an adult bookstore to view pornography, which I had not seen since I was a boy. And from there it was all downhill. As one decision, "I will," led to another, "I will," which led to another, "I will," which finally landed me in a gay bar, night after night, drinking excessively, engaging in promiscuity.
I had been a struggler. A struggler in the church is someone who has a secret temptation and does not want to bring that temptation to light. And so, as such a person, I embraced a gay identity. I worked hard to tell myself, "This is all right with me, even if it's not all right with God."
Which lasted for about a year. And then the conflict really surfaced when I realized, and yet, I miss my fellowship with the church. I miss abiding in Christ. I miss the communion of the Holy Spirit. That's when someone came along, a gay friend of mine, who said, "I know a church where you can be both, where you can be openly gay and openly Christian, and they will teach you how to re-read the Bible in a way to show there is no conflict between the two." And I thought, "I got to hear this."
And that was when I stepped into the local congregation of the Metropolitan Community Church. And walking into that church and hearing the pro-gay interpretation of scripture, on the one hand I thought, "Yes, this is answered prayer." On the other hand, I thought, "This is kind of sloppy theology." And yet, even if it's wrong, is it so terribly wrong?
I mean, if I embrace this and I identify myself as a gay Christian, isn't that a step in the right direction? I'll stop my promiscuity. I'll stop my excessive drinking. I'll clean my act up and I'll live as a gay Christian man, responsible and moderate in his lifestyle, and still proclaiming Jesus Christ.
So much so that eventually I joined the staff of the church, and I began preaching a pro-gay theological message. I began teaching Bible studies. I was active with the church. And I thought, "Finally I have landed at a place of peace. I am no longer denying my sexuality. I am no longer denying my Christianity. It has all come together. Thank You, Lord." But something interesting was happening in the midst of all that.
I was embracing something that was doctrinally satisfying to me, but also very dangerous. In 2021, it's becoming increasingly common. And there are many believers, many church leaders even, who are saying that perhaps this issue, what the Bible does or does not say about homosexuality, is one of those secondary issues we can agree to disagree on, but still be in fellowship with each other over.
And there are such issues, aren't there? I mean, there are some doctrinal matters we can agree to disagree on and it doesn't break our communion. Good night, somebody's right about the rapture of the church. Wherever you have landed, pre-trib, mid-trib, post-trib, somebody's wrong, somebody's right, but I can't imagine us breaking fellowship over that.
Sexuality is another matter. Sexual sin is aggressively condemned in 21 out of all of the New Testament books. The first case of recorded church discipline occurred over a sexual sin within the congregation, and you'll remember Paul was so put out with the Corinthian church when he said, "There's sexual sin in your midst and you're actually proud of it." This is not a secondary issue. This is a primary issue.
In a pluralistic culture, yes, there's room to agree to disagree. Within the body of Christ, no. There is no room for diversity on something as basic as the definition of marriage and family. On this point, we dare not compromise. I had embraced a serious error, but the peace I was feeling was soon evolving into something different. I was beginning to feel angry.
There's a good reason for that. I had embraced this. I wanted to believe it was true. But there was a still small voice telling me it wasn't. My own conscience, my own foundation in the Word of God, and the conviction of the Holy Spirit were all conspiring together to tell me, "No, Joe, you're embracing a lie."
John Fuller: You're listening to Joe Dallas on Focus on the Family and if you'd like to learn more about how to share the love of Christ well with those in the homosexual lifestyle, let me encourage you to get a copy of Joe's book called The Gay Gospel, how pro-gay advocates misread the Bible. We can send that out to you when you make a donation of any amount to the work we're doing here at Focus on the Family. make that a monthly pledge or one-time gift.
We'll send the book and also include a free audio download of Joe's entire presentation with some extra content. Uh, donate and request those at focusonthefamily.com/broadcast or call for details, 800, the letter A, and the word family. 800-232-6459. Let's go ahead and return now to more from Joe Dallas.
Joe Dallas: Now, when my conscience is telling me something that I don't want to hear and I decide, "No, I'm not going to listen to that," then if you come along and tell me something that is in harmony with what my conscience is telling me, I'm going to be like, "La la la la la la la la la la. I don't want to hear it."
I don't want to hear you. And if you keep saying that, you become my enemy. The body of Christ became my enemy. Many vocal leaders within the body of Christ were saying, "This is not God's will." And I didn't want to hear that. The more I heard it, the madder I got.
And the madder I got, the more I decided, "I don't want to just coexist with these people. I want to shut them up." And that's when I morphed from being religious to militant. Now, a gay militant is someone with a twofold agenda: the normalization of homosexuality and the silencing of anyone who objects to that normalization.
I no longer believed just in seeking to normalize homosexuality in the culture. I, like many others, wanted to stamp out the voice of anybody who disagreed with that normalization. And I found a new drug when I made that decision. Now, I had given up drugs when I was a kid when I was first born again. I stopped using dope.
And even at my worst, I never relapsed back into using drugs, but I found a whole new one that could be generated within me. Rage. Getting angry, getting angry over what I saw as an injustice, getting angry over people I believed to be the oppressors.
And man, there is nothing like the adrenaline rush you get when you feel you have a holy cause. They're the enemy, we're the righteous, and we go to battle with them. And in that I felt so pumped and so powerful that when I look at the behavior of people throwing public tantrums and burning down buildings and getting in people's faces, I abhor it, but I get it.
I became addicted to gay militancy. I felt so powerful debating people on college campuses and marching in parades and getting in people's faces about that. And all of the evangelical fervor I had applied to preaching the Gospel when I was a kid, I now applied to converting the culture and the church to a pro-gay position. That was my righteous cause.
And I loved it. Except, again, but God. Because there was something still testifying against me, even in the midst of that. Occasionally, people who had known me when I was part of the Bible-believing church would run into me in the supermarket, or they'd call me up, and they'd say, "Joe, I hear you've gone gay. I hear you're with a gay church. I hear you are really aggressive about it. What happened to you, man? I knew you when you were such a Christ-centered guy. And you knew the Word of God. How are you justifying this?"
And like anyone who was well indoctrinated, I had all my answers ready. And I could rattle them off and look so calm and so convinced, end the conversation and go home and get drunk, to kill the anxiety I was feeling. Because I knew, I am being affected by what these people say, but I dare not let them know because that would be a concession.
I have to be right. Because if I'm not right about this, what is my life built on? The whole foundation is going to crumble. No, no, no. I have to be right. I have to be right. Except as more and more time went by, I began to question how right I really was, until early in January of 1984, when the conviction of the Holy Spirit was becoming overwhelming at a time when, by all reasonable causes, it shouldn't have been.
I mean, my life was going very well. Good job, wonderful apartment, good social life. I was in the best physical shape I'd ever been in. I was in so many ways a happy man who seemed to have so much together as my openly gay, proud, religious self would tell you. And yet, I'd wake up in the middle of the night wondering, "Are you kidding yourself?"
And at work, sometimes I'd feel like I'm about to cry. And finally in January of 1984, one night I got home from a workout at the gym, sat down in front of the TV. I saw an old friend of mine on a Christian TV show who was testifying about his own secret struggle with alcoholism.
And he said, "I never gave the church a chance. I kept it hidden, and that's why it overtook me." And I thought, "Okay, Joe, let's be honest. Did you ever give the church a chance?" "No, I didn't."
Way back then, I had decided, "The church will never understand this temptation I have. They'll think I'm a freak. They'll reject me. And if I decide that they'll reject me, that will justify my leaving the church." Because I had never said to any of my Christian friends at the time, "This is a temptation I have. Will you please pray with me because I don't want to give into it?"
Oh, if only I had done that, what a different course my life would have taken. Today, if only so many women and men would do that, what a different course their lives would take. And that was when I realized, "Okay, it's time to get honest."
And that's when I turned out all the lights in my apartment, and I knelt down, and I said, "Lord, I am ready to admit it. If I have been wrong, I want to know that I've been wrong." And that was the night I became repentant.
The repentant individual struggling with same-sex desires is the person who comes into the church saying, "I do have these desires. I'm not going to keep it a secret. I know it will be a sin if I yield to them. I want to grow in Christ. So what do I do now?" That was the question I posed to the church when I repented, relocated, and got into good Bible-believing fellowship.
Because I knew, I can't do it the way I did it before. I can't pretend that these feelings are not a part of what I deal with. And as I began making friends in the church, a whole new experience for me, by the way, making honest, authentic friendships. The guys in my church took me in and said, "Yeah, we want you. Worship with us. Join our choir. Join our softball team."
And so I could spill it all out with them. "This is where I've been. I lived as an openly gay man. I wrestled with these feelings. I don't know what to do about it." There are some struggles we all relate to, right? The struggle to mouth off or punch somebody out or lie or be greedy. And there are some struggles that are more unique that only a minority of us experience, like homosexuality, but good night, it's all fruit from the same tree, isn't it? The sin nature.
So these guys said to me, "Look, we don't expect anything out of you that we don't expect of ourselves. Get into the Word of God. Develop your prayer life. Abide in Christ. Fellowship with us. Be honest with us about your struggles and we will be honest with you about ours. Seek the will of God and the calling of God in your life and let's all grow together and become the men of God that we are meant to be."
They knew how you love a brother who is seeking discipleship and accountability. And this is why I often say, "You don't have to have a PhD in psychology or sociology to know how to minister to a homosexual person. Do you know the Word of God and do you have the heart of Christ? You're in." And you're equipped, as they were.
Interestingly enough, when I prayed my prayer of repentance, I said, "Lord, I have sinned against You." And I know I have the heart of a rebel. And I probably always will. You are bigger than my heart. Take a hold of this rebel. Make me obedient. I didn't even think to ask, "Change me," as in, "Make me straight. Give me a wife," et cetera.
But I did find, oddly enough, that as I abided in Christ and stayed in fellowship and grew in grace and sought God's will, the homosexual temptations reduced and became less and less strong. And I started having a desire for a marriage and a family life. But I didn't know how on earth that was going to happen because I really didn't have the kind of a
Featured Offer
The Gay Gospel is a compelling and thoughtful guide for anyone seeking clarity in a complex and often polarizing conversation within the church. Joe Dallas combines biblical depth with real-world counseling insight, equipping readers to respond to pro-gay advocates with both conviction and genuine compassion. Rather than offering clichés, the book provides clear, Scripture-based answers and practical ways to engage others with Christlike love. If you want to understand the LGBT movement and communicate your beliefs with grace and confidence, this book is an invaluable resource.
Past Episodes
Video from Jim Daly
Featured Offer
The Gay Gospel is a compelling and thoughtful guide for anyone seeking clarity in a complex and often polarizing conversation within the church. Joe Dallas combines biblical depth with real-world counseling insight, equipping readers to respond to pro-gay advocates with both conviction and genuine compassion. Rather than offering clichés, the book provides clear, Scripture-based answers and practical ways to engage others with Christlike love. If you want to understand the LGBT movement and communicate your beliefs with grace and confidence, this book is an invaluable resource.
About Focus on the Family
About Jim Daly
Jim Daly
Jim Daly is President of Focus on the Family. His personal story from orphan to head of an international Christian organization dedicated to helping families thrive demonstrates — as he says — "that no matter how torn up the road has already been, or how pothole-infested it may look ahead, nothing — nothing — is impossible for God."
Daly is author of two books, Finding Home and Stronger. He is also a regular panelist for The Washington Post/Newsweek blog “On Faith.”
Keep up with Daly at www.JimDalyBlog.com.
John Fuller
John Fuller is vice president of Focus on the Family's Audio and New Media division, leading the team that creates and produces more than a dozen different audio programs.
John joined Focus on the Family in 1991 and began co-hosting the daily Focus on the Family radio program in 2001.
John also serves on the board of the National Religious Broadcasters.
Contact Focus on the Family with Jim Daly
Mailing Address
Focus on the Family
8605 Explorer Dr.
Colorado Springs, CO
80920-1051
Toll-free Number
(800) A-FAMILY (232-6459)